Lesson 13 of 17
The Lighthouse · stone 13Foundation5 minute read

Prompts that work

Using a writing prompt as a way in: turning it into a particular person, place and moment, starting inside that moment, and following the piece wherever it goes.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-14

The Lighthouse on its headland, with the keeper’s cottage and a writing desk in the window.
The Lighthouse · Writing process and habit, stone 13 of 17

A door, not a question

A prompt is something to start from: a word, a situation, a first line. It is not a question you have to answer, and you do not have to stay on it. It has done its job the moment you are writing.

A prompt that names a subject leaves you somewhere to think, while one that names a moment leaves you somewhere to stand.

Some prompts get you writing at once, and some leave you staring. The difference is usually how particular they are. “Write about loss” is a whole subject; there is nowhere to stand in it. “A woman finds her own name carved inside a cupboard in the house she has just bought” already has a person, a place and something happening. You can see the first sentence from here.

You will not always get the second kind. But you can make it, in a minute or two, from the first.

Make it particular

When a prompt is a big word, ask it four small questions before you write a line.

Four small questions turn a prompt that names a subject into a moment you can begin writing in.

Who? One person, or one creature, with a name or at least an age and a job. Not people in general.

Where and when? A place you could walk into, at an hour or on a day that matters: the slipway on the morning the ferry is sold.

What is in their hands? An object gives the scene something to do and often holds the whole idea: the bell, the compass, the saucer of milk.

Then write a first line that starts inside that moment. The big word does not need to appear anywhere. A good piece about a promise may never use the word, because it is busy showing a boy keeping one.

A small limit can help too: one room, ten minutes of story time, two people. A narrow space is easier to fill than an open one.

Start inside, then follow

The first sentence of a response is often the writer clearing their throat: “I’m not sure what to say about doors.” In a freewrite that is fine; write it and keep going. But if you have made the prompt particular first, you can skip it and start with someone doing something.

Then let the piece go where it goes. A prompt about a door may turn into a piece about a lodger’s loneliness, and the door may never be opened. That is not a failure to answer. It is the prompt working.

Example

Making “a door” particular

A writer gets a one-word prompt from her list and spends two minutes on it before she writes.

The cellar doorhorror

Prompt from my list: a door.

Too big. Which door?1 The cellar door at the house on Pell Street, the one we were told never to prop open.

Who is at it? Not me. A lodger, Mrs Orme, the winter after the war, holding a lamp.2 When? The evening the knocking from the cellar starts answering hers.

In her hands: the key, and a saucer of milk she tells herself is for the cat3.

First line: “Mrs Orme set the saucer down on the top step, because whatever was knocking had stopped when she did that last night.”4

  1. “Too big. Which door?”She notices the prompt is a subject, not a moment, and narrows it with a question.
  2. “A lodger, Mrs Orme, the winter after the war, holding a lamp.”A particular person at a particular time. It is not the writer herself, which gives her room to invent.
  3. “a saucer of milk she tells herself is for the cat”The object in her hands holds the story: she is afraid, and she is pretending not to be.
  4. ““Mrs Orme set the saucer down on the top step, because whatever wa…”A first line already inside the moment. It has a person, a place, an action and a question.

Before and after

Two responses to “waiting”

The one faultIt writes about the prompt’s idea in general instead of a particular person in a particular moment.

Weaker versionWaiting (first version)

Waiting is one of the hardest things a person can do. Everyone has waited for something: a letter, a call, someone who said they would come. The minutes stretch out and you start to imagine everything that might have gone wrong. Maybe they changed their mind. Maybe they never meant it. You hold on to hope because letting go would mean admitting it is over, and nobody wants to be seen giving up, especially in public.

Showing the weaker version.

Both pieces are about the same feeling: someone has not come, and hope is wearing thin. The first even has the same worry about being seen to give up.

But the first talks about waiting. It speaks to “everyone” and “you”, and the reader has nobody to watch. The second puts one woman on one bench with two coffees, a departures board and a stranger with a dog. Nothing in it says how waiting feels, and we know exactly how it feels for her, from the cold cup she will not put down.

Follow the rule by default. Break it only when breaking it does a job.

The exception

When to break it

Sometimes the general is what you want. A personal essay, a prose poem or a freewrite to find out what you think about a subject can begin with the big word and circle it. This lesson is about getting into fiction quickly, not about the only way to write.

And if a prompt does nothing after a couple of minutes, even made particular, swap it for another. There is no prize for sticking with one that is not working. If you have a story of your own on the go, the best prompt may be the next scene in it.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 2 min

The first move

Your prompt for today is “a lie”. You have ten minutes. Which first move is most likely to get you writing?

Key takeaway

A prompt is a way in, not a question. When it is a big word, make it particular: who, where and when, and what is in their hands. Start inside the moment, and follow the piece wherever it goes, even away from the prompt.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

A week of prompts, made ready

Write seven prompts for your daily sessions, each turned into a person, a place and moment, an object and a first line.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.