Find out which kind of stuck
Being stuck feels like one thing: the cursor blinks and nothing comes. It has several possible causes, and they call for different responses. So before you reach for a tactic, take two minutes to diagnose. Name the scene, and write one sentence about what is going wrong there.
Which kind of stuck?
- A story problemYou do not know what happens next
- A problem of nerveYou know what happens and dread writing it
- The character will not do itEach push towards the plan makes the scene go false
- You are boredDoes the story need this scene?
- You are worn outNot a writing problem; no tactic will fix it
You do not know what happens next. The story has run past your plan or your instinct. This is a story problem.
You know what happens and do not want to write it. The scene is hard (a death, a battle with nine moving parts) or you are afraid of doing it badly. This is a problem of nerve.
The character will not do it. Each time you push them towards the planned action, the scene goes false. Often the draft is telling you something about the character, or about the plan.
You are bored. If a scene bores you to write, it is worth asking whether the story needs it, or whether it starts in the wrong place.
You are worn out. Nothing is wrong with the book. You have a cold, or a deadline at work, or a child who is not sleeping. That is not a writing problem, and no writing tactic will fix it.
Match the tactic to the stall
If you do not know what happens next, work on the story. Ask what each person in the scene wants right now. List ten things that could happen, fast and without judging them; the obvious ones come out first and clear the way. Or go back to the last page that felt alive, because the wrong turn is often a little way behind the place where you stopped.
Match the tactic to the stall
If you are dreading the scene, lower the bar. Write it as a rough summary, or as bare dialogue. Or skip it: type [THE FUNERAL GOES HERE], write the scene after it, and come back when you know what the later chapters need from it.
If the character will not act, ask them. Write an interview in which you put the question and they answer in their own voice. Or write the scene from another character’s point of view, to see your lead from outside. You may find that the character is right and the outline is wrong.
Every tactic has a price. Skipping ahead leaves a hole that later scenes have to guess around. An interview produces pages that will not be in the book. Changing the plan to suit the character can unpick chapters you thought were finished. A tactic has paid for itself when it gives you a next action: one thing you can do at your next session.
Example
Asking the character
A fantasy writer’s mercenary is supposed to betray the fortress he has been guarding. The scene has failed four times. She opens a blank page and questions him.
Q. The outline says you betray the garrison in chapter eleven. I’ve tried it four times and you keep stalling at the postern gate.1 Why?
A. Because you have me doing it for money.2
Q. You’re a mercenary.
A. I was a mercenary when I took the contract. I have eaten with these people for a winter. Ishbel’s boy calls me uncle.
Q. So you won’t open the gate.
A. I didn’t say that.3 I’d open it for a reason I could say out loud. Not for a purse.
Q. What reason?
A. Give me a thing they did. Something I found out. The grain they’re hiding while the lower town starves, say.
Q. That isn’t in the book.
A. Then put it in. Chapter nine, when I’m sent to the cellars.
Next action: write a short cellar scene for chapter nine.4 He finds the grain. Then try the gate again.
- “I’ve tried it four times and you keep stalling at the postern gate.”The diagnosis comes first. She names the scene and the kind of stall: the character will not do what the plan says.
- “Because you have me doing it for money.”The answer puts the fault in the motive she gave him, not in the scene she has been rewriting.
- “I didn’t say that.”He disagrees with her. An interview is doing its work when the character says something the writer did not expect.
- “Next action: write a short cellar scene for chapter nine.”She stops as soon as she has one task small enough for a single session. The interview itself will not go in the book.
Before and after
A writer’s account: nine days at the same line
The one faultThe writer pushes harder without asking what kind of stuck this is.
The interrogation scene had been open on my screen for nine days. I knew it was the scene. Every evening I read it from the top, changed a word in the first paragraph, and stared at the line where Inspector Radu sits down. On the tenth day I told myself to stop being precious, set a timer for an hour and made myself stay in the chair. I wrote the sitting-down line six different ways. When the timer went I had the same half page and a headache.
Both writers spend nine days at the same sentence, and both decide on the tenth to do something about it. The first treats the stall as a failure of discipline and answers with an hour in the chair. The hour is real effort. It is aimed at the wording of a line, and the wording was not the problem.
The second spends a minute on one question and writes down the answer: she does not know what her inspector knows. That turns a block into a missing decision. The tactic follows from it. She leaves the scene, writes a rough page that settles the matter of the register, and comes back to a scene that can now begin.
Nothing else differs between the two. The second writer did not find more willpower. She found out what she was stuck on.
The exception
When to break it
Tactics are for stalls in the story. Some things that stop a draft are not that.
Not every stall needs a tactic
If you are ill, grieving or exhausted, do less, or stop for a while. A stretch of not writing that has a cause outside the book is not a block, and it does not need solving. The draft will keep.
Sometimes a stall is the draft doing its job. If every tactic fails at the same scene, the fault may lie further back: a premise that cannot carry the book, or a turn the earlier chapters did not set up. That calls for stepping away to look at the structure, and it may take a good deal longer than one session.
And for some writers the best tactic is none: a walk, a night’s sleep, a week on another piece. Leaving a problem alone is a sound method as long as you set a date to come back to it. Without the date, a rest can turn into an abandoned draft without anyone having decided it.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
The scene she is avoiding
A writer knows exactly what happens in her next scene: her heroine’s mother dies. She has not opened the file for three weeks. Which tactic fits this stall best?
Key takeaway
Being stuck is a symptom with several causes. Name the scene and the kind of stall before you choose a tactic, choose the one that answers it, and stop when you have a next action small enough for one session.
