Three questions under every custom
Any group of people who have to live together builds a culture: a kingdom, a mining town, a family firm, a school staff room. Writers of invented worlds know they have one to design. So do writers of realist and historical fiction: in any genre, the place has to make sense from the inside.
Power, scarcity, belief
- Who has power?Often not the person with the title
- What is scarce?Water, land, daylight, parking spaces
- What do people believe?About luck, the dead, shame, family
Three questions get you most of the way.
Who has power? Who decides, who can punish, who can say no and make it stick? Often it is not the person with the title.
What is scarce? Water, land, daylight, husbands, parking spaces, the owner’s attention. Whatever there is not enough of, people will have built rules around.
What do people believe? About luck, about the dead, about shame, about what a person owes their family.
A custom is a place where these meet. It protects something scarce, or serves someone powerful, or keeps faith with a belief, and often it does more than one. Once you know which, the custom stops being decoration.
Follow it one step further
The test of a society on the page is consequence. Suppose that in your town only widows may sign contracts. Follow it. Marriage to a much older man becomes a business plan. A husband’s sudden death will be looked into with care. Somebody, somewhere, is pretending to be a widow. Each of those is a scene, and each was waiting inside the rule.
One rule, three scenes
- The ruleOnly widows may sign contracts
- A business planMarriage to a much older man
- A sudden deathLooked into with care
- A pretenderSomebody is pretending to be a widow
Ask as well who does the work: who grows the food, who empties the bins, who sits up with the dying. A city with a palace and no farms, or an office with a chief executive and no cleaner, is a stage set.
Example
A culture of six cars
A driver on a station taxi rank takes a fare. Nothing here is exotic, and nobody explains anything. Work out the rule, and who enforces it.
At ten past midnight there were six cabs on the station rank and, so far that night, there had been four fares1. Bartek was fifth in line. He had been fifth for fifty minutes.2
The woman came out of the side entrance instead of the front, dragging a case, and stopped beside his door. “Airport?”
The airport was the best fare the rank saw in a week. He looked up the line.3 Gopal, at the head of it, was asleep with his seat back, or seemed to be.
“Get in,” Bartek said.
When he came back at two the rank was as he had left it, less one. He pulled in at the tail. Nobody looked round. At four his battery light came on, and he walked up the line with the cables in his hand. Each window he came to went up before he reached it, quite gently4, all the way to the front, where Gopal was awake now and reading the paper5.
- “six cabs on the station rank and, so far that night, there had bee…”What is scarce. Every rule this rank has follows from there being more cars than passengers.
- “He had been fifth for fifty minutes.”The custom, given without being stated: fares go to the front of the line, and you wait your turn however long it takes.
- “He looked up the line.”That glance is the moment he decides to break the rule.
- “Each window he came to went up before he reached it, quite gently”The punishment. Nobody is in charge and nobody says a word. Power belongs to the line, and it is used by withholding a favour on the night he needs one.
- “Gopal was awake now and reading the paper”The man whose fare it was does not need to lift a finger. The custom has cost Bartek far more than the airport run paid.
Colour or conflict
A custom earns its place in a story when somebody’s wish runs into it. A festival described is colour. A festival that forbids the one thing your heroine needs today is plot. For any custom you have built, find the character it blocks, and ask what keeping it costs and what breaking it costs.
A festival, two ways
Then let the locals behave like locals. People do not explain their own customs to each other. They keep them, bend them, break them and punish one another for it, and the reader learns the rule by watching.
Before and after
A festival passed through, and a festival in the way
The one faultThe custom is only colour: Iona wants nothing that the Open Days could prevent, so she walks through the festival and out the other side.
Iona came down into Sennet on the third of the Open Days, leading her mule. No coin had changed hands in the town since the first frost, and none would for six days more. A baker pressed a loaf on a stranger and would not hear thanks, and two old men were arguing over which of them had been given the better goose. On every doorstep stood a bowl of walnuts for whoever passed. Iona took a handful, as a traveller was expected to, and ate them as she walked. In the mule-dealer’s yard a man was writing in a great book, under the names of half the town, what he had given that day and to whom. She watered the mule at the well, and by noon she was on the road to the pass.
The first version invents a good custom, nine days after the first frost in which nothing may be bought or sold, and uses it as scenery. Iona needs nothing from Sennet, so the town’s way of life cannot touch her.
The second version changes one fact, that her mule is lame, and lets the rest follow from it: a mare to be had, a dealer who will not sell, a pass about to close. The custom becomes a wall. She has silver and cannot spend it. The only way to get a mare is to accept one as a gift, and a gift here is written in a book and has to be answered within the year. She is leaving for good. So to cross the pass she takes on a debt she means to default on, in a town that keeps records.
We have also learned why the custom exists: for nine days everyone in Sennet is put in debt to everyone else, and coin would let them settle up and walk away.
The exception
When to break it
Plenty of stories need only a sketch of a society; a chase or a fairy tale can run on a few strokes.
When the society can be lighter
Real customs are not all logical. Many have outlived their reasons, and one or two that nobody can account for can make a place more believable.
No society is of one mind. If everyone in your town keeps the custom gladly, you have drawn a poster. Give it sceptics and hypocrites.
When you draw on the customs of real, living people, the questions change. The custom is part of somebody’s life, and it deserves the same research and care as any other fact you put on the page.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which custom is doing work?
Four sentences from four novels set in the same river towns. In which one is a custom producing conflict for a character?
Key takeaway
Build a society from its pressures: who has power, what is scarce, what people believe. Follow each custom to its consequences, find the character it blocks, and show what keeping, bending or breaking it costs.
