A letter, not an advert
Once the list exists, you have to write to it. The question every writer asks is what to say when there is no new book.
What the reader learns to expect
Start from the reader. They joined because they enjoyed your writing, so every letter should give them a little more of it: something to read, see or think about that they could not get anywhere else. A letter that only asks, to buy, review, share or follow, teaches the reader that your name in their inbox means a request. After a few of those they stop opening, and the letter that matters, the one about the new book, goes unread.
So give in every letter, and ask in few. When you do ask, ask for one thing, plainly, and only when there is a reason: a book is out, a book can be ordered, a library could stock it.
What to give
You have more to give than you think, because you spend your days inside your books.
- The story behind itA place, a document, a real thing a scene grew from
- Your worldA map, a cut scene, a minor character’s moment
- A book you lovedBy someone else, and why
- A questionOne they might enjoy answering
The story behind the story: a place you visited, a document you found, the real thing a scene grew from. Something from your world: a map, a cut scene, a short piece about a minor character. A book you loved by someone else, and why, which readers of your kind of book are often glad of. A question they might enjoy answering. And news, when there is news.
One of these is enough for a letter. A short letter that gives one good thing is better than a long one that tries to give everything.
A rhythm you can keep
Choose how often to write by asking what you could keep up for a year while still writing your books. For most people that is less often than they first think. A letter that arrives on the first Sunday of every month, every month, does more than a weekly letter that stops in March.
Keeping it going
- Choose a rhythmOne you could keep for a year
- Tell readersAt sign-up and in the welcome
- Keep an ideas pageAdd to it as you write
- Send on the dayShort if the month was thin
Tell readers the rhythm when they join, and keep it. Keep a page of letter ideas open while you work, and add to it whenever something turns up: a fact, a photograph, a book. When the day comes, you choose from the page instead of starting from nothing. If a month is thin, send a short letter.
Example
A monthly letter from a historical novelist
A historical novelist’s March letter. She writes to her list once a month.
Subject: The keeper’s logbook, and a question about tea1
This month I spent two days in a record office reading the logbooks of a real lighthouse, and I want to tell you about one entry. On a calm night in 1871, the keeper wrote only: “Wind nil. Lamp lit 6.40. Wife unwell.”2 The next night: “Wind nil. Lamp lit 6.38.” Nothing more about his wife, ever. I have been thinking about those three words for a fortnight, and they have found their way into chapter nine.
The new book, for those who asked, is at 61,000 words and the keeper’s daughter has just done something I did not plan3.
A book I loved this month4: a novel about a woman who mends clocks in a city under siege. Small, quiet and devastating. I read it in two sittings.
And one piece of news: the paperback of The Lamp Room is now in libraries across the county. If your library does not have it, you can ask them to order it.5
Until April,
Elspeth
- “The keeper’s logbook, and a question about tea”The subject line promises a story, not a sale.
- ““Wind nil. Lamp lit 6.40. Wife unwell.””The gift: a real find from her research that no reader could get anywhere else, and the way it fed the book.
- “the keeper’s daughter has just done something I did not plan”Progress on the new book in one line, told as a story, not a word count alone.
- “A book I loved this month”A recommendation of someone else’s book. Generous, and useful to readers of her kind of book.
- “If your library does not have it, you can ask them to order it.”One ask, with a reason (news), and an easy one: it costs the reader nothing.
Before and after
One ask or three
The one faultIt asks the reader for three things at once.
This month I finally visited the old radio telescope I based the listening station on. The dish is rusting now and sheep graze under it, which I found oddly moving. There is a photo below.
The Long Listen comes out on 9 August. You can pre-order it now from the link below. If you have read the first book, please leave a review, and if you know someone who would enjoy it, please share this letter with them.
Next month: the scene I cut, and why.
Dev
Both letters open with the same gift, the rusting telescope and the sheep, and both end with a promise for next month. The difference is the middle.
The first asks for a pre-order, a review and a share in three sentences. Each is reasonable alone. Together they turn a letter into a list of jobs, and a reader faced with three requests often does none of them.
The second has one piece of news and one ask, offered as a convenience: “if you would like it on the day”. It is easy to say yes to, and easy to ignore without guilt, which is what keeps the next letter welcome.
The exception
When to break it
A launch letter is different. When a book comes out, readers on your list expect to hear about it, and the news is the gift. Even then, one clear ask, where to get the book, does more than five.
Some writers write only when there is a book, and say so at sign-up. That is a rhythm too, and an honest one. What matters is that readers know what to expect.
And you may sometimes need to skip a month. A two-line note saying so, and when you will be back, keeps faith with readers better than silence.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
A month with no news
A fantasy writer’s next book is months from finished, and her monthly letter is due. She has no news. Which letter is most likely to keep her readers opening the next one?
Key takeaway
Give something in every letter: the story behind a scene, a piece of your world, a book you loved, a question. Ask for at most one thing, and only when there is a reason. Choose a rhythm you could keep for a year, tell readers what it is, and keep an ideas page so each letter starts from something.
