The shortest thing you will write about the book
A title is a piece of writing about your book that is only a few words long. It has two jobs.
- Say its kind“Murder”, “earl”, “dragon”, “orbit”: four shelves
- Be passed onEasy to say, to hear and to spell
The first is to say what kind of book this is. Words carry associations. “Murder”, “earl”, “dragon” and “orbit” each point to a different shelf before a page is turned, and a title built from one of them makes a promise about what is inside. A title that points to the wrong shelf is a problem even when it is beautiful, because the person it attracts is not the person the book will please.
The second job is to be passed on. Sooner or later one person will try to tell another about your book. A title that is easy to say, easy to hear and easy to spell can make that trip. One that has to be spelled out, or that nobody can quite remember, may not arrive.
Five places to find one
Many titles are made out of something the book already has. Five sources are worth trying in turn: a thing the story turns on; a person, by name or more often by role; a place; an event; and a phrase, which may be a few words lifted from the book or a saying bent to fit it.
Prefer the particular
Whichever you choose, prefer the particular to the general. “Shadows”, “secrets”, “destiny” and “journey” could go on almost any novel, and that is the trouble with them: they do not say which one. A useful test is to try your title on a different book of the same kind. If it fits just as well, keep looking.
A subtitle is a second line under the title. In fiction it is often a plain label, such as “A Novel” or the name of the series. In non-fiction it does real work. A common division is that the title catches the eye and the subtitle says plainly what the book is, who it is for or what the reader will get from it.
Example
One book, five candidates
This is a page from a writer’s notebook: one line about the book, then five possible titles, each taken from a different source.
The book: a fantasy novel. A bell-founder’s apprentice discovers that the great bell she is casting for the cathedral is meant to call something up from under the city, and that her master knows it.
The Bell1
The Founder’s Apprentice2
Under Saint Averell’s3
The Night of the First Ringing4
What the Bronze Remembers5
- “The Bell”A thing. It is true and easy to say, but it would fit a ghost story, a school story or a history of clocks. Nothing in it says fantasy, and nothing says danger.
- “The Founder’s Apprentice”A person, by role. “Apprentice” suggests a young lead and a trade to learn. Said aloud, though, “founder” sounds like someone who starts a company, so the title needs the cover to explain it.
- “Under Saint Averell’s”A place. “Under” does good work, because it points at whatever is down there. The cost is a name that a listener would have to ask you to spell.
- “The Night of the First Ringing”An event. It promises that the bell will ring and that something will follow. It is the longest of the five and still easy to say.
- “What the Bronze Remembers”A phrase. Metal that remembers is strange enough to suggest magic, and “bronze” belongs to this book and few others. This is the one that could not be moved to another novel.
Before and after
Any book, or this book
The one faultThe title is made of general words and could sit on any novel.
Title: Shadows of Destiny
The book: a historical novel. In a salt port in the 1780s, a customs clerk finds a second set of account books hidden in the weigh-house, and has to decide whether to report the harbour master, who is also his father-in-law.
The book is the same in both. Only the title has changed.
“Shadows of Destiny” is easy to say and sounds like a novel. That is all it does. Try it on a fantasy epic, a family saga or a war story and it fits each of them, which means it tells a stranger nothing about a clerk, a port or a choice.
“The Second Ledger” is a thing from the story. “Ledger” puts us among accounts and offices, and “second” says there is one too many, so the title has the book’s secret in it without giving the plot away. It would not fit the fantasy epic. That is the point of it.
The exception
When to break it
A title does not work alone. It sits on a cover, above a blurb and beside an author’s name, and those can carry some of the load. A quiet, plain title can be right when the cover shows the kind of book at a glance. A single large word can be right when that word truly is the book’s subject, though it then leans harder on everything around it.
A title does not work alone
Some titles play against their shelf on purpose: a comic novel with a solemn title, or a very long title used as a joke or as a taste of the narrator’s voice. That works when the mismatch is itself the signal.
While you are drafting, none of this matters. A working title only has to tell you which file to open. The real one often turns up late, in a line of the finished draft.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
The jam-maker’s book
A gentle, funny village mystery: at the summer fair a prize-winning jam-maker is found poisoned, and the retired postmistress works out who did it. Which title tells a stranger most truly what kind of book this is?
Key takeaway
A title promises a kind of book and has to survive being said aloud. Build it from something particular that your book has (a thing, a person, a place, an event or a phrase), test it on a stranger’s ear, and let a subtitle say plainly whatever the title leaves out.
