The letter promises, the pages show
When an agent asks for pages, with the query or after it, the pages are where the letter’s promise is tested. The letter says who the book is about, what goes wrong and what kind of book it is. The pages are the first chance to see whether that is true, read by someone who does not know you and has other pages waiting.
Promise and evidence
What is asked for varies: a number of pages, the first chapter or the first three, sometimes the whole book. It is usually the beginning. Send the opening of the book as it stands, not a favourite chapter from the middle, unless the instructions you were given ask for something else. If the opening is not the part you would choose to show, that is a note about the opening.
Reading your opening against your letter
Put your query beside your first pages and read them together, asking four questions.
- The personOn the page early, as the letter describes them
- The troubleOr its first shadow, before the pages run out
- The kind of bookIn tone as well as genre
- The voiceThe one your comparable titles suggest
Is the person from the pitch on the page early, and as the letter describes them? Does something of the promised trouble show itself, even as a shadow, a wrongness or a question? Is this the kind of book the letter named, in tone as well as genre: a comedy that is funny from the first page, a thriller that is tense? And does the voice sound like the book your comparable titles describe?
If the pitch’s trouble arrives on page sixty and the agent has asked for ten, the letter and the pages describe two different books. That does not mean the inciting event has to be on page one. It means the opening should already belong to the story the letter told.
Clean, and ended well
A stranger reading quickly will stop at the slips you have stopped seeing: a name spelt two ways, a doubled word, a sentence revised in half, a verb left in the wrong tense. Before each round, read the pages aloud, or print them, or change the font, so that they look new to you.
The last read
- Read it aloudSlowly, every word
- Check the namesAnd every spelling of them
- Find the breakA scene or paragraph end near the length asked
- Lay it outAs the instructions say
If you are asked for a number of pages, look at where that number falls. Ending at the close of a scene or a paragraph reads better than ending in the middle of a sentence; check the instructions for how strict the number is before you go a little under. And lay the pages out as asked, with whatever spacing, font and heading the instructions name.
Example
Pages read beside the letter
A fantasy writer checks the ten pages an agent has asked for against her own query.
The Thorn Gate: the first ten pages, read beside the letter1.
The letter says: stubborn Wren, a hedge-layer’s apprentice, finds a gap in the old hedge that no one else can see, and something is coming through it. It calls the book a comic fantasy.
Wren: on the first line, laying a hedge in the rain. On page 2 she refuses to stop for lunch until the stretch is done.2 That is the stubborn Wren the letter promised.
The trouble: the gap is in chapter 3, on page 31. Ten pages will never reach it.3 But on page 4 the hedge sheds every leaf overnight, in June, and Wren is the only one who minds.4 Move that to the first page and see how it reads.
The kind of book: the letter says comic. The first four pages are weather and grief for her mother.5 Cut the grief to a line, and start her argument with her master sooner.
Page 10 stops halfway through a sentence. End at the scene break on page 9 instead, if the agent’s instructions allow a little under6.
- “read beside the letter”The method: the pitch and the pages, side by side.
- “On page 2 she refuses to stop for lunch until the stretch is done.”The person on the page, doing what the letter said she would be: stubborn.
- “Ten pages will never reach it.”The problem, stated plainly: the trouble the letter promised is outside the pages asked for.
- “But on page 4 the hedge sheds every leaf overnight, in June, and W…”The trouble’s first shadow is already there. Moving it up keeps the letter’s promise without rewriting the plot.
- “The first four pages are weather and grief for her mother.”The tone does not match the letter’s “comic”. That is a promise broken, however good the pages are.
- “if the agent’s instructions allow a little under”Where to stop is checked against this agent’s instructions, not assumed.
Before and after
The pier first, or Jo first
The one faultThe opening starts with the pier’s history, so the person and the trouble the letter promised wait until after it.
The pier at Gullhaven was built in 1887 by a man who had made his fortune in bootlaces and wanted the town to know it. It had survived two fires, a storm that took the end off it, a ballroom that nobody danced in after 1960, and forty years of council meetings about whether to pull it down.
Jo Penrose read the will twice in the solicitor’s office, then asked whether she could give it back.
“It doesn’t work like that,” said the solicitor. “Your great-aunt has left you the pier.”
“The whole pier?”
“And its debts.”
The query for this book pitches a comic novel about a woman who inherits a failing seaside pier and everything owed on it. Both versions use exactly the same words. Only the order changes.
The first opens on the pier’s history. It is well written, and a little funny, but a reader who has just read the letter is waiting for the woman, and she arrives after a paragraph of bootlaces and council meetings.
The second opens on Jo, in the solicitor’s office, trying to give the pier back. Within a few lines the reader has the person, the trouble (a pier, and its debts) and the comic tone the letter promised. The history now arrives as something Jo has just been landed with, which makes it funnier.
The exception
When to break it
Some books open with a frame, a document or a prologue for good reasons, and a stranger can tell when it is doing work. If yours is one of them, the test is the same: does the opening already feel like the book the letter described? If it does, keep it.
If an agent asks for something other than the opening, such as a chapter of your choice, send what they ask for. And if the instructions say to send exact pages, with no stopping early, follow them and let the page end where it falls.
A quiet literary novel may hold its central trouble back for a long time. Then the voice and the situation carry the promise, and the letter should promise that kind of book.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Before the pages go
Your query pitches a fast thriller about a kidnapping. Your first chapter is a slow account of the hero’s childhood, and the kidnapping happens in chapter four. An agent asks for the first ten pages. What is the most useful thing to do?
Key takeaway
Your first pages are the evidence for your letter. Read them side by side and check that the person, something of the trouble, the kind of book and the voice the letter promised are already on the page. Send the book’s own opening, end it at a natural break within what the instructions allow, and read it slowly once more for slips before each round.
