Feedback you can use
Before you send a story to strangers, show it to two or three readers you trust, and ask them better questions than “What did you think?”. Ask where they started to skim, what they expected to happen next, where they were confused, and which line stayed with them. Any reader can answer those honestly, writer or not.
Questions a reader can answer
Readers are good at telling you where something is not working, and less reliable about how to fix it. So write down what they say without arguing, wait a day, then decide. When two readers stumble in the same place, look hard at that place.
Read every word of the guidelines
Every magazine, anthology and competition that takes short stories publishes submission guidelines. They say what length it accepts, what kinds of story it wants and does not want, how to lay out the manuscript, how to send it, and which rights it is asking for. Read all of them, for every market, every time, because they differ and they change.
- LengthThe word limits, low and high
- What they wantGenres and subjects, and what they refuse
- How to sendLayout, the cover letter, when they are open
- Other marketsWhether simultaneous submissions are allowed
- RightsWhat they are buying, and whether it must be unpublished
Then do exactly what they say. A story over the word limit, in the wrong format or sent while the market is closed may be turned away unread, however good it is.
Simultaneous submissions and first rights
A simultaneous submission is the same story sent to more than one market at once. Some markets accept them and some do not, and the guidelines say which. If a story is out with several markets that allow it and one accepts it, withdraw it from the others straight away. A multiple submission is something else: more than one story sent to the same market.
What first rights mean
- UnpublishedYou can offer first rights
- Published anywhereIn print, online, or on your own blog
- From then onIt can only be offered as a reprint
When a market buys a short story, it is usually buying first rights, the right to be the first to publish it. Once a story has appeared anywhere, it can only be offered as a reprint. Posting it yourself on a blog or a public website usually counts as publishing it, so check before you share a story online. And keep a simple record of where each story is, when you sent it and what came back.
Example
A cover letter that does its job
A short cover letter for a market that accepts simultaneous submissions. Notice how little it says.
Dear Editor,
Please consider my short story “The Lamplighter’s Ledger”, a piece of historical fiction of 3,400 words1, for your spring reading period.
This is a simultaneous submission, as your guidelines allow2, and I will withdraw it at once if it is accepted elsewhere. It has not been published before, in print or online.3
I have not had fiction published yet.4 Thank you for your time.
Yours sincerely,
Marta Ruiz
- “a piece of historical fiction of 3,400 words”Genre and length first, both checked against the guidelines before sending.
- “This is a simultaneous submission, as your guidelines allow”Says plainly that the story is out elsewhere, and only because this market allows it.
- “It has not been published before, in print or online.”One sentence that tells the editor the first rights are still free.
- “I have not had fiction published yet.”Honest and brief. A first-time writer does not need to apologise or to oversell; the story does the work.
Before and after
The same request, asked two ways
The one faultIt asks for an opinion and a fix instead of questions a reader can answer.
Here’s my new story, “The Night Porter”! It’s a thriller of about 3,200 words, and it’s the second draft.
Please tell me honestly what you think of it. Be brutal, I can take it, and if you can see how to make it better, go ahead and mark it up.
Thanks so much for doing this.
Both notes are friendly, and both go to the same two readers with the same draft.
The first asks them to judge and to repair. Kind readers tend to answer that with a polite “I liked it” and a few changed commas, and the writer learns very little.
The second asks four things the readers can answer from memory: where they skimmed, what they guessed, where they were lost and what stayed. The answers point at places in the story, which is where revision starts.
The exception
When to break it
Not every story needs to be sent out. Some are practice, and some are for a few people you love. Sharing a story with friends by email is not publishing it, and it does not use up its first rights.
Other ways to share
Writing groups and workshops can work differently from two trusted readers: there, many people respond at once, and it helps to listen for the points that several of them make. And if a market’s guidelines are unclear about something, such as whether a story you once posted and then took down counts as published, it is fine to ask the market or to mention it in your cover letter. Telling the editor plainly is better than guessing.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Accepted elsewhere
Three markets accept simultaneous submissions, and you send your story to all three. The second one accepts it. What do you do?
Key takeaway
Ask two or three readers specific questions before you send a story out. Read every market’s guidelines in full and do exactly what they say. Know whether the market takes simultaneous submissions, withdraw at once when a story is accepted, and remember that a story can be published for the first time only once.
