Finished is not the same as ready
Typing the last line of a draft is a real achievement. It is not the same as being ready to publish. When you publish your own book, nobody stands between the draft and the reader to say “not yet”. That job is yours, and you are the person least able to see the book as a stranger will.
From last line to ready
- A finished draft
- Revised, big to small
- Read by strangers
- Edited and proofread
Writers feel a book is finished at many points: when they are proud of it, when they are sick of it, when they have read it so often that the words slide past. None of these feelings tells you what a reader will meet on the page. So the question to ask is not “does it feel finished?” but “what do I know about it?”
Five questions, each with evidence
A readiness check is five questions, each answered with something you can point to.
The readiness check
- Revised top downStructure, then scenes, then sentences
- Read by strangersReaders of the genre who owe you nothing
- Patterns dealt withWhat more than one reader noticed
- The promise keptWhat its kind of reader comes for
- Edited and proofreadErrors in the opening pages show first
Has it been revised from the top down? Structure, then scenes, then sentences. Name the passes you made.
Has anyone who owes you nothing read it to the end? Friends and family are kind. A reader of your genre who does not know you is more useful, and whether they finished is the first thing to ask.
Have you dealt with what more than one reader noticed? A pattern matters more than a single opinion.
Does it keep the promise of its kind? A romance that ends with the lovers apart may be a fine book that disappoints the people it is sold to.
Has it been copyedited and proofread? Online shops let browsers read the opening pages, so errors there are the ones a stranger sees first.
Write the answers down. Where the answer is no, write what it would take.
Three good answers
The check ends in one of three decisions. Publish, on a date. Fix named things first, then publish. Or not this book: some first novels teach their writers how to write the second, and that is not wasted work.
Where the check can end
Two traps pull in opposite directions. One is publishing because you are tired of the book. The other is polishing it for ever because publishing is frightening. If readers of your genre finish the book and their notes are small, another full rewrite is unlikely to be what it needs. Set a date, and give your new ideas to the next book.
Example
A check on one page
A fantasy writer runs the check on her novel. Notice that every answer points at something that happened, and that the decision follows from the gaps.
Book: The Saltmarsh Crown, fantasy, about 104,000 words.
Revised: three passes, structure first. Reverse outline done in March; two chapters cut, the siege moved earlier.1 Line pass finished in June.
Read by others: five readers, two of them strangers from a fantasy reading group. All five finished it.2 Three said the middle of part two dragged, and two of those meant Tamsin’s chapters in the marsh.3
Fixed since: the marsh chapters cut from four to two. Not yet read again by anyone.4
The promise: a heist inside a royal court, with magic that costs the one who uses it. The cost shows in every set piece, and the heist is under way by chapter six.
In a sentence: a forger who can copy any seal must steal the queen’s own before the court notices it has two of everything.
Not done: copyedit, proofread.
Decision: not yet. Send the new marsh chapters to two of the five. Book a copyedit for September. Check again on 1 October.5
- “Reverse outline done in March; two chapters cut, the siege moved e…”Evidence of a structural pass: things that changed, not a claim that she revised.
- “two of them strangers from a fantasy reading group. All five finis…”Readers who owe her nothing, and the first fact worth knowing about them: they got to the end.
- “Three said the middle of part two dragged, and two of those meant…”A pattern, narrowed to a place in the book.
- “Not yet read again by anyone.”The gap is named. A fix nobody has read is a guess.
- “Decision: not yet. Send the new marsh chapters to two of the five.…”A clear decision, the steps it takes, and a date to look again.
Before and after
Felt, or known
The one faultThe decision rests on how the writer feels about the book, not on evidence about it.
Book: Second Spring at Larkhill, romance, 78,000 words.
I have been working on this book for three years and I know it inside out. I have read it so many times that the sentences slide past me now, so there can’t be much left to change. It feels finished, and honestly I am tired of it.
Decision: publish in May.
Both notes end with the same decision, and the first may even be right. The trouble is that nothing in it could tell her. Three years of work, knowing the book inside out, words that slide past, being tired of it: each is a fact about the writer.
The second note says what has been done to the book and what readers made of it. Four strangers finished it, one pattern came up and has been dealt with, and a copyeditor has been through it. The decision is the same, and now it stands on something. It also shows what is left: a proofread, with a month set aside for it.
The exception
When to break it
Not every book needs every step before it goes out. A short story or novella published partly to learn the process can go with a lighter check, as long as you are honest with yourself about what it is. Serial fiction, published chapter by chapter, is revised in public by design. And a writer with an editor who has worked on several of their books may need fewer outside readers.
What stays the same is the basis of the decision: what you know about the book, not how you feel about it today.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
The best sign
A writer is deciding whether her thriller is ready to publish. Which of these is the best sign that it is?
Key takeaway
Ready is a decision made on evidence: revision from the top down, strangers who read to the end, patterns dealt with, the genre’s promise kept, and a text that has been edited and proofread. Write the answers down, name what is missing, and decide: publish on a date, fix named things first, or let this book teach the next one.
