Readers with readers
Some readers have readers of their own: people who write about books on a blog, in a newsletter, on video or on a review site, and whose followers trust their taste. A review from one of them puts your book in front of people who already read that kind of book, in the voice of someone they like.
From a list to a review
- Find them through compsWho reviewed books like yours?
- Read the policyWhat they take, and how to ask
- A short, personal pitchWhy them, the book, the offer
- Send if they say yesThen leave the rest to them
They are not a service. Most review for love, in their spare time, with more books offered to them than they could ever read. So treat a pitch as a polite request to a busy reader, not an order.
Find them the way you found your readers: through books like yours. Look for who reviewed the books you would compare yours to, and read some of their reviews. Keep a short list with their name, where they review, what they read, what their policy says, when you wrote and what came back.
Read the policy, then write briefly
Many reviewers publish a review policy: the genres they read, the formats they take, whether they review self-published books, how to ask, and whether they are open to requests at all. Read it before you write, and do what it says. A pitch for a romance to someone who reads only horror, or a file attached when the policy asks for a query, wastes their time and yours. If they are closed, do not pitch; note it and look again later.
- Their name, and why themA review of theirs you read
- The book in two linesWho, what trouble, what kind
- The factsGenre, length, formats, date
- An easy offerA copy if they would like one
Then keep the pitch short. Use their name, and say in a sentence why you are writing to them in particular, which a review you read will tell you. Give the book in two or three lines: who, what trouble, what kind of book. Give the facts they need: genre, length, formats, publication date. Offer a copy, and make it easy to say no.
Nothing in return
Ask whether they would like a copy. Do not ask for a good review, a rating or a date, and offer nothing in return for a review: no payment, no gift, no prize. Shops have rules about reviews, and so do the advertising laws of some countries; a reviewer who was given a free copy will often say so in the review, and that is as it should be. Read the current rules of the shops where your book is sold.
The ask
After you press send, let it go. No reply is an answer. If the policy allows, one short follow-up after a few weeks is fine; after that, cross them off. If a review comes, thank them for reading, not for the verdict. If it is unkind, say nothing: it was written for their readers, not for you.
Example
A pitch for a court fantasy
A fantasy writer pitches a reviewer she found through a review of a book like hers.
Subject: Review request: The Glasswing Court (fantasy of manners, ebook or paperback)1
Dear Wen,
I found Tea Among Dragons through your review of a court fantasy last month2, where you said you wanted “more books where the duels are verbal”. Mine is one of those, I hope.
The Glasswing Court is a fantasy of manners: a forger’s daughter is sent to a glass palace to marry a prince who is not what he seems, and survives by her wits and her pen3. It is about 95,000 words, the first of two, and comes out on 3 October.4
Your policy says you take ebooks and paperbacks from independent authors by email query.5 Would you like a copy, in either format? If it is not for you, or your pile is too high, no reply is needed.6
With thanks,
Isla Fenn
- “Review request: The Glasswing Court (fantasy of manners, ebook or…”The subject line says what the email is, the kind of book and the formats, so the reviewer can decide before opening it.
- “I found Tea Among Dragons through your review of a court fantasy l…”Why this reviewer, in one sentence, from something she really read.
- “a forger’s daughter is sent to a glass palace to marry a prince wh…”The book in one sentence: who, what trouble, and the promise. No ending.
- “It is about 95,000 words, the first of two, and comes out on 3 Oct…”The facts a reviewer needs to plan.
- “Your policy says you take ebooks and paperbacks from independent a…”She shows she has read the policy, and does what it asks.
- “If it is not for you, or your pile is too high, no reply is needed.”An easy way to say no. It makes yes easier too.
Before and after
Two lines or the whole plot
The one faultIt tells the whole plot, ending included, instead of the set-up.
Dear Marcus,
I enjoyed your piece on spy novels set in the Baltic, and your point that the best ones make the reader do the sums. The Cutout is that kind of book, I hope.
Analyst Kay Brennan is sent to Riga to close down an informant, finds that he has been feeding her own service lies for years, and goes on the run with him. They cross three borders, she discovers her handler was behind it all along, she kills him in a ferry terminal in Tallinn, and in the end she returns to London and takes his job.
It is 88,000 words and comes out on 2 May. Would you like a copy, ebook or paperback? No reply needed if it is not for you.
Best wishes, Noor Haddad
Both pitches open with the same reason for writing to Marcus and close with the same facts and the same easy offer. Only the middle differs.
The first summarises the book from start to finish: the borders, the handler, the ferry terminal, the job. A reviewer now knows how it ends before deciding whether to read it, and has had to read a synopsis to find out what the book is.
The second gives the set-up and the question that drives the book, then stops. It is shorter, and it leaves the reviewer wanting to know who wanted it that way, which is the feeling the book itself depends on.
The exception
When to break it
Not every reviewer has a policy. Then keep the pitch shorter still, and ask first whether they would like a copy at all.
Local newspapers, radio and magazines often work differently: they may prefer a short press release with a local angle, sent to a named editor, and they may want it weeks before publication. Find out how each one likes to be approached, and follow that instead of the blogger’s pattern.
And readers you know personally are a different matter from reviewers you have never met. Some shops have rules about reviews from people close to the writer. Read them before you ask a friend.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Closed for now
A reviewer who loves exactly the kind of book you have written says on her blog: “Closed to review requests for now. I will reopen when my pile is down.” What should you do?
Key takeaway
Find reviewers through reviews of books like yours, and read each one’s policy before you write. Keep the pitch short: their name and why them, the book in two lines, the facts, and an easy offer of a copy. Ask for nothing but whether they would like it, offer nothing in return, follow up once at most, and leave the review to them.
