Not everyone
Every plan for telling people about a book starts with a question that is easy to skip: who, exactly, is going to enjoy this? “Anyone who likes a good story” feels generous, but it gives you nowhere to go. You cannot write to everyone, stand in every shop or post in every group.
Two ways to describe a reader
The readers most likely to enjoy your book already exist. They are reading something like it now. So describe them by what they read, not by their age, their job or what they do at the weekend. A reader of slow-burn workplace romance might be nineteen or seventy. What they have in common is the kind of book they reach for, and that is something you can find.
This is not about shrinking your ambitions. A clear picture of the first readers is how a book reaches the next ones: they are the people who tell their friends.
Three questions
A reader note answers three questions.
A reader note
- What else they readKinds of book, and a few you have read
- Where they lookNamed groups, sites, shelves and shops
- The words they useTheir phrases for what they love and dislike
What else do they read? Name the kinds of book, and if you can, two or three books you have read yourself that sit near yours. The lesson on comparable titles covers choosing them.
Where do they look for books? Be particular: not “online” but which reading groups, which review sites, which shelf in which library, which bookseller. Places where readers already gather are where you will later offer a free story, pitch a reviewer or leave a flyer.
What words do they use? Readers have their own language for what they love: “slow burn”, “locked room”, “found family”, “no cliffhanger”. Their words are the ones that will catch their eye in a blurb, a post or a newsletter.
Listen before you guess
You do not have to guess the answers. Read the reader reviews of books like yours, the warm ones and the cross ones, and copy out the phrases that come up more than once. Praise tells you what to promise. Complaints tell you what to warn about, or what your book does differently.
Listening first
- Read the reviewsWarm and cross, of books like yours
- Copy out the phrasesThe ones that come up more than once
- Join as a readerRead the group for weeks before you post
Then go where those readers are, as a reader first. Join the group and read it for a few weeks before you say anything about your own book. Look at what the library has on display, and ask a bookseller what people who buy that kind of book ask for. You are not collecting leads. You are learning what this corner of the reading world sounds like, so that when you do speak, you sound as if you belong in it.
Example
A reader note for a cosy fantasy
A fantasy writer answers the three questions for her novel about an inn at a river crossing, then writes down what the answers change.
What they already read: cosy fantasy where the stakes are a home, a friendship or a small business, not the end of the world1. Found families. Very little violence. Many also read gentle mysteries and slow romance.
Where they look for books: two online reading groups for cosy fantasy, the fantasy shelf at the town library2, the “if you liked this” lists on review sites, and the bookseller at Harrow Street Books, who hand-sells them.
Their words, from reviews of the books I would compare mine to: “a hug in a book”, “low stakes, big heart”, “I want to live there”3, “the found family made me cry”. Their complaints: “too slow in the middle”, “not enough of the dragon”.4
What this changes: my blurb leads with the inn and the people in it, not the war in the background. I say “low stakes” out loud. I will not chase readers of dark, violent fantasy, however many of them there are.5
- “cosy fantasy where the stakes are a home, a friendship or a small…”She describes her readers by the kind of book they choose, not by who they are.
- “two online reading groups for cosy fantasy, the fantasy shelf at t…”Places she can name and visit. Each one is somewhere a later step can happen.
- ““a hug in a book”, “low stakes, big heart”, “I want to live there””Copied from reviews of books like hers. These are phrases a reader would search for or stop at.
- “Their complaints: “too slow in the middle”, “not enough of the dra…”The cross reviews are as useful as the warm ones: they show what to warn about, or what her book does better.
- “I will not chase readers of dark, violent fantasy, however many of…”Choosing readers also means choosing who not to chase. A reader who wanted a war would be let down by her inn.
Before and after
The same romance, two notes
The one faultIt describes the readers by age and way of life instead of by what they read.
Who they are: women between twenty-five and fifty-five who live in cities, work long hours and are juggling a job and a family.
Where they look: they are busy, so they are mostly online, and they like coffee, travel and cooking programmes.
What they will enjoy: the banter between Dee and Marco, the restaurant kitchen, the slow build and the happy ending.
Both notes end with the same list of what the book offers. The difference is in how they find the people who would want it.
The first describes a kind of person. Nothing in it says where such a person looks for a romance, and plenty of women in cities who like coffee do not read romance at all. The writer cannot act on it.
The second describes a kind of reading. It names the books those readers already pick up and the places they talk about them, down to a monthly thread on the very trope the book is built on. Every line points somewhere the writer can go.
The exception
When to break it
Some facts about a reader’s life do matter, when they change what or where they read. A children’s book has two readers, the child and the adult who buys it, and you need to know where the adult looks. A book about grief may find readers through support groups as well as shelves. A story set in one city may sell first in that city. Use such facts when they point to a place or a need, and leave out those that only make the picture feel complete.
And a reader note is a starting point, not a fence. If people you did not expect take to your book, listen to them too, and add them to the note.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which note can you act on?
A writer is about to tell people about her thriller, set on an oil platform in a storm. Which line from her reader note will help her most in deciding where to start?
Key takeaway
Describe your readers by what they already read, not by who they are. Answer three questions: what else they read, where they look for books, and what words they use. Find the answers by reading reviews of books like yours and joining readers’ groups as a reader first, then let the answers decide where you go and what you say.
