Choosing early readers
Before or at release, a small group of readers can have the book early: people who read your kind of book and might, if they enjoy it, say so where other readers can see it.
Who to ask
- Reads your genreAnd finishes books
- Owes you nothingNot family, not close friends
- Has time nowCan read before or soon after release
- AskWith a free copy and no pressure
Choose them for what they read, not for how close they are to you. Family and close friends are a joy to share the book with, but their praise is easy for strangers to discount, and some shops have rules about reviews from people with a personal connection to the author. Look instead among people who have read your work before, your newsletter if you have one, reading groups for your genre, and readers who review books like yours.
Ask for honesty, and mean it
The request is simple. Here is a free copy. If you read it and want to, an honest review would be welcome wherever you buy books. That is all.
An honest request
- A free copyWith no strings
- Honest, if they wishNot a rating, not a deadline
- Nothing for a reviewNo gifts, money or draws
- Say it was freeWhere the shop’s rules ask for it
Ask for an honest review, not a rating. Offer nothing in return for a review: no gifts, money or prize draws. Do not ask readers to leave out that they had a free copy. Many shops, and the advertising rules of some countries, expect a reviewer who was given the book to say so. Each shop sets its own review rules and they change, so read the current ones for every shop you sell in before you write your request.
When the reviews come
Read them if it helps you, and stop if it does not. It is usually wise not to reply to reviews, argue with them or ask for one to be changed. A review is a reader talking to other readers, not to you.
What to do with reviews
Thank your early readers for reading, not for the stars. A low review is not a failure of the launch. A book that delights some readers leaves others cold, and an honest mix of opinions is easier for a stranger to trust than a row of perfect scores.
Example
A request that respects the reader
A science-fiction writer sends her book to readers who asked for it. Notice what she asks for, and what she does not.
Hello,
You asked to hear when The Long Orbit was ready1, so here it is, three weeks before it comes out. The ebook is attached, free, with no strings2.
If you read it and feel like saying something about it in public, an honest review on the shop where you buy your books, or on a reading site, would be very welcome. Good, bad or lukewarm, it helps other readers decide.3 If you don’t get round to it, or it isn’t for you, that is completely fine.4
One small thing: some shops ask reviewers to mention that they were given a free copy, so please do if you post5.
Thank you for reading.
Esther
- “You asked to hear when The Long Orbit was ready”These readers chose to be here, which is the best start an early-reader list can have.
- “free, with no strings”The copy is a gift, not a trade.
- “Good, bad or lukewarm, it helps other readers decide.”She asks for honesty and explains why it matters, without naming a rating.
- “If you don’t get round to it, or it isn’t for you, that is complet…”No pressure, said plainly.
- “some shops ask reviewers to mention that they were given a free co…”The free copy is out in the open, as many shops’ rules expect.
Before and after
A rating, or an honest review
The one faultThe request asks for a particular rating instead of an honest review.
Here is your early copy of Wyrmwood. If you enjoy it, a five-star review on release day would really help me. Thank you for reading!
The two notes are almost the same length and equally warm. The first asks for five stars. That puts the reader in an awkward spot: if they thought the book was good but not that good, they can either inflate their review or say nothing, and many will say nothing. It also asks for something that some shops do not allow.
The second asks for an honest review, whatever the reader thought. It makes it easy to post something true, and that is the kind of review other readers believe.
The exception
When to break it
Early readers are not the only way to reach readers, and a writer who would rather not run an early-reader list can simply publish and let reviews come in their own time. Some shops and reading sites run their own review programmes, with their own rules; if you use one, follow its terms instead of this lesson’s.
What does not change: reviews are honest or they are worth little, and nothing you offer should depend on what a reader says.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
The fair request
Which of these is the fairest thing to say when sending an early reader a free copy of your novel?
Key takeaway
Choose early readers for what they read, not for how close they are to you. Give them the book freely and ask for an honest review only if they want to give one: no rating asked for, no reward offered, and no secret made of the free copy. Read each shop’s current review rules, thank readers for reading, and leave the reviews themselves alone.
