A comparison is a shortcut
When you tell a friend about a film, you often reach for another film: “It’s like that one with the lighthouse, but funny.” A comparable title, or comp, does the same for a book. In a query letter, a proposal or a line of sales copy, it says that a reader who liked that book may like this one, and says why.
A statement about kind
A comp is a statement about kind. It tells a stranger where on the shelf your book would sit and who might pick it up. It is not a statement about quality or success, and when it starts to sound like one it stops being useful. “The next great sea novel” claims a rank. “A sea story told by the ship’s cook” describes a book.
Every book named in this lesson is invented. That lets you watch how a comp line is built without arguing over whether the comparison is fair.
Three habits of a useful comp line
Say what each book lends. A bare title leaves the reader guessing which of a novel’s many qualities you mean. Attach the quality: “the closed-house plotting of…”, “the dry narrator of…”. A comp can lend its kind of plot, its voice, its setting, its tone or the age of reader it is written for.
- Say what each lends“The dry narrator of…”
- A different job eachOne for the premise, one for the tone
- Books you have readBooks you could talk about for five minutes
Give each comp a different job. Two books that resemble yours in the same way say one thing twice. One book for the premise and another for the tone fix your book from two sides, as two compass bearings fix a position on a chart.
Choose from what you have read. Name only books you have finished and could talk about for five minutes. A comp picked from a list of popular titles is a guess, and it can promise a kind of book you did not write. If the books you have read offer no comparison, the honest next step is more reading along your own shelf.
Example
Two comps, two jobs
This paragraph comes from a letter introducing a historical mystery about a customs clerk in a salt port.
THE SECOND LEDGER is a historical mystery. It combines the slow, document-by-document detection of1 Henryk Kowalski’s The Weighing Room with the divided family loyalties of2 Josefine Dalgaard’s Salt Wife. Like both, it is set in a working port and has no professional detective.3
- “the slow, document-by-document detection of”What the first book lends: a kind of plot. The reader now knows this mystery is solved through paperwork and patience.
- “the divided family loyalties of”What the second book lends, and it is a different thing: an emotional situation. The two comps do not overlap.
- “Like both, it is set in a working port and has no professional det…”What all three share. This sentence names the shelf. Nothing in the paragraph says the book is as good as the others, or will sell as they did.
Before and after
Titles alone, and titles with reasons
The one faultThe books are named, but nothing says what they have in common with this one.
NEVER THE CAKE is a contemporary romance. It is comparable to Second Oven by Cordelia Beaumont and Soup for the Night Shift by Kenji Yamada.
The same two books appear in both versions. In the first they are simply listed. A reader who knows both has to guess the likeness: is it the setting, the humour, the kind of couple, the ending? A reader who knows neither learns nothing at all.
The second version is seven words longer. “The workplace rivalry of” says what kind of couple this is. “The gentle, food-filled comedy of” says what the book feels like to read. Now even a reader who has never heard of either title knows something true about the manuscript, because the reasons carry the information and the titles only vouch for it.
The exception
When to break it
Two comps with reasons is a pattern, not a requirement.
When the pattern bends
If you cannot find an honest comparison, describe the shelf in plain words: “a quiet ghost story for people who dislike gore”. That serves better than a forced title. The formula “X meets Y” can be right when both halves are true and the collision is the hook. It fails when one half is there for its fame.
A classic can serve when your book answers it directly, as a retelling does. It tells the reader about your book’s ancestry. It cannot say what your book sits beside today, so if that is the purpose of the line, pair it with something of your own time. The same caution applies to any book so widely known that it has been compared with everything: it no longer narrows the field.
A film, a series or a game can stand as a comp where the likeness is real. And whoever you are writing to may have published their own wishes about comps. Theirs come before anything here.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which line places the book?
A writer has finished a quiet historical novel about two sisters who run a river ferry. All the books named below are invented, and she has read them. Which comp line tells a stranger most about her book?
Key takeaway
A comp line places your book by naming others of its kind. Choose books you have read, say what each one lends, give each a different job, and compare kinds, not ranks.
