The labels that travel with the book
A book in a shop window can be judged by its cover. A book in an online shop or a library catalogue is often found before it is seen, through the labels attached to it. Those labels are its metadata: the title and subtitle, the author’s name, the series name and number, the description, the category it is filed under, and the keywords, which are search words or phrases supplied along with the book.
- Title and subtitle
- Author and seriesThe name, and the series number
- The description
- Category and keywordsThe shelf, and a reader’s search words
If you publish your own work, you write these labels. If a publisher does it for you, knowing your shelf still sharpens your pitch and your comps. In both cases this is a writing task. Its subject is your book, described truthfully in the words a reader would use.
This lesson does not cover the rules of any shop. Each has its own lists, limits and policies, and they change. Read the current help pages of the shop you are using. The thinking below comes before that, and it carries over.
Category: one true shelf
A category is a promise about the whole book. To choose one, ask what question keeps a reader turning the pages, and how the book ends. A love story set on a space station is a romance if the question is whether the couple get together and the book ends when they do. It is science fiction with a love story in it if the question is whether the station survives.
Narrowing the shelf
- “Mystery”True of a village puzzle
- Light, bloodless mysteriesTruer, where the shelf exists
- Too narrowDescribes only part of the book
Then go as narrow as is still true. “Mystery” is true of a village puzzle with no blood in it. A narrower shelf for light, bloodless mysteries, where one exists, is truer, and the people browsing it are looking for that very thing. Stop narrowing at the point where the label would describe only part of the book.
Keywords: a reader’s phrases
A keyword is better thought of as a key phrase. Picture someone who would enjoy your book and does not know it exists. What might they type? Probably not “novel” or “fiction”. More likely they would type a short phrase for what they are in the mood for: a setting, a kind of person, a situation, a tone, a period.
Three tests for a key phrase
- True of this book?Another writer’s name fails here
- Point to it?In the description
- Says something new?Nothing your other phrases say
Three tests help. Is the phrase true of this book? Can you point to the part of the description that makes it true? Does it say something that none of your other phrases says? Another writer’s name or another book’s title fails the first test, because it describes their book and not yours.
Example
A worksheet
This is a writer’s worksheet for a historical romance: one paragraph describing the book, then the category and six keywords she has chosen.
The book: a slow-burning love story set in a fishing village in the 1890s. A widowed net-maker and the new schoolteacher are thrown together when the school roof comes down, and the village has opinions about it. The ending is happy.1
Category: Romance, historical.2
Keywords: widow finds love again3; schoolteacher hero; slow-burn courtship; village gossip; nineteenth-century fishing village4; gentle romance, no explicit scenes5.
- “The ending is happy.”The fact that settles the shelf. The question all through is whether these two will end up together, and they do. That makes the book a romance and not a historical novel with a love story in it.
- “Category: Romance, historical.”The kind of story first, then the narrower shelf. Both words are true from the first page to the last.
- “widow finds love again”A situation, in four plain words that a reader in the mood for it might type. The description makes it true: “a widowed net-maker”.
- “nineteenth-century fishing village”Setting and period in one phrase. It does not repeat “village gossip”, which is about the community and not the place.
- “gentle romance, no explicit scenes”A tone, and a warning. This phrase will turn some people away, and they are people the book would have disappointed.
Before and after
Words anyone could use, and phrases only this book can
The one faultEach keyword is a single general word that fits thousands of books.
The book: a fantasy novel. A bell-founder’s apprentice discovers that the great bell her guild is casting for the cathedral is meant to call something up from under the city, and that her master knows it.
Keywords: fantasy; magic; book; story; fiction; novel; city.
The description is the same in both. Every keyword in the first list is true: the book is fantasy, it has magic in it, it is a novel. That is the trouble. The same seven words are true of a shelf a mile long, so they do nothing to pick this book out, and four of them (“book”, “story”, “fiction”, “novel”) say only that it is a book.
Each phrase in the second list can be traced to the description: the apprentice, the guild, the cathedral city, the summoning, the master who knows, the foundry, the thing below. No two say the same thing. A person who typed any one of them would be glad to be shown this novel.
The exception
When to break it
Narrow and specific is the default, and it gives way in a few cases.
Where narrow gives way
A book that truly sits across two kinds has to choose a first shelf, and the ending is usually the tie-breaker. A broad category is the right one when no narrow shelf is true. Filing a book on a busy shelf where it does not belong brings it people who will feel misled.
A single word can be a good keyword when the word is rare and exact: “selkie” does more than many a phrase. And tone words that warn people off are as useful as those that draw them in.
Last, these labels are worth looking at again. If the book changes in revision, or you learn that people are finding it for a reason you did not expect, check that the labels are still true.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
A year at sea
A novel follows a ship’s doctor through a year at sea in the 1820s: a storm, an outbreak of fever and a mutiny. In one chapter a sailor tells a ghost story. The doctor’s wife appears in two letters. Which category is truest to the whole book?
Key takeaway
Metadata is your book described in a reader’s terms. Choose the narrowest shelf that is true of the whole book. Write keywords as short phrases a reader might type, each naming a different true thing. Check that the title, description, category and keywords all promise the same book, and read your shop’s own current instructions for the mechanics.
