Sentences have a beat
Read a page aloud and you will hear it. Every sentence has a length, and a run of sentences has a beat. The beat is still there when you read in silence.
Read it aloud
When each sentence is about as long as the one before, and built the same way, the beat becomes a drone. No single sentence is at fault. The trouble is the row of them. The ear stops listening, and the important things go past at the same weight as the unimportant ones.
Varying the length cures the drone. It also hands you a tool. A short sentence that follows longer ones stands out, so whatever you put in it stands out too.
What each length is good for
Short sentences suit facts, shocks and decisions. They stop the reader for a moment, so spend one on a thing you want noticed.
What each length is good for
- Facts, shocks, decisionsA stop: spend one on a thing to notice
- The ordinary workMedium sentences, so long as no one length runs on
- Anything that keeps goingA chase, a crowd, a view, a thought
Long sentences suit anything that keeps going: a chase, a crowd, a view the eye travels across, a thought that will not stop. A long sentence makes the reader hold several things at once and carries them along without a rest.
Medium sentences do most of the ordinary work. Rhythm does not mean getting rid of them. It means not letting one length run on until the reader stops hearing it.
Shape counts as well as length. Five sentences that each begin with “She” and a verb will drone even if the word counts differ. Open one with a place or a time. Join two with “and”. Let one be a question.
You do not need to count while you draft. Rhythm is a job for revision, and the best instrument for it is your own voice reading the page aloud.
Example
Listen to the lengths
A woman is going into an office building where she has no right to be. Notice which facts get the shortest sentences.
The lift took forty seconds to reach the ninth floor, and Renske spent them counting the cameras she had already counted twice from the street. Two in the lobby.1 One in the lift, above the panel, with a red light that might have been for show. The doors opened on a corridor of grey carpet and closed office doors, and she walked it the way she had practised, not fast, bag on the left shoulder, eyes on her phone as if a message had just come in.2 Room 914 was the fourth on the right. The key card worked.3 Inside, someone had left the desk lamp on.4
- “Two in the lobby.”Four words, and not even a full sentence. It sounds like counting, which is what she is doing. The next sentence is longer, so the pair does not turn into a list.
- “The doors opened on a corridor of grey carpet and closed office do…”Forty-one words for one unbroken walk. The reader goes down the corridor with her and is given no place to stop, which is how it feels to her.
- “The key card worked.”The shortest full sentence in the passage holds the fact the whole plan depended on. After the long walk it lands like a held breath let go.
- “Inside, someone had left the desk lamp on.”A different opening from the sentences before it, and a middling length. The surprise is saved for the final words.
Before and after
The same crossing, two rhythms
The one faultEvery sentence is the same length and the same shape.
The drover reached the ford an hour before dark. The river had risen since he crossed it in spring. Brown water covered the stones he used as markers. His forty cattle bunched behind him on the bank. The lead cow walked in up to her knees. She stopped there and would not go further. The drover waded in beside her with the rope. The current pulled the legs out from under him.
The first version has eight sentences of eight to ten words each, and most of them open with “The” and a noun. The words are well chosen and the events are clear, but the man going under the water arrives at exactly the pace of the man arriving at the river.
The second version tells the same events in almost the same words, in five sentences. The long opening lets the reader take in the risen river in one look, as the drover does. Then come two medium sentences and a five-word one: “She would not go further.” That is the moment the crossing goes wrong, and now it has a sentence to itself. Nothing was added. Only the joins and the full stops moved.
The exception
When to break it
Variety is a default, not a goal. Sometimes the drone is the effect you want. A run of short, flat sentences can carry shock or exhaustion, or a narrator who is holding something down. A run of long ones can carry a mind that cannot switch off. Books for children who are learning to read keep their sentences short for good reason.
When variety is not the aim
There is a failure on the other side as well. Long, short, long, short is a pattern too, and the ear learns it as quickly as it learns a drone. And a short sentence spent on something minor (“She sat down. It was a chair.”) throws its emphasis away. If the content does not deserve a stop, do not give it one.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Where does the weight fall?
A writer wants the reader to stop on one fact: the door was already unlocked. Which version does that best?
Key takeaway
Mix your sentence lengths so the reader keeps listening, and choose what goes in the short ones. A short sentence is a spotlight. Point it at the fact, the turn or the decision you most want seen, and let longer sentences carry whatever moves without stopping.
