A flashback has to be asked for
A flashback is a scene set in the past, dropped into a story that is moving forward. Smaller pieces of the past belong to the lesson on dosing backstory, and the mechanics of getting in and out (a trigger, a sentence or two in the “had” form, an anchor on the way back) are in Handling time. This lesson is about an earlier decision: whether the flashback belongs, and where.
Where a flashback earns its place
- The present raises a questionWhy did she stop?
- A triggerSomething in the room calls up the past
- The scene in the pastIn by “had”, then the plain past
- Back with an anchorThe same room, the same object
- The present reads differentlyHer next line means something new
A flashback stops the story and asks the reader to care about something already over. It earns that stop when it does two things. It answers a question the present has just made the reader ask: why did she flinch, why will he not take the boat past the buoy. And it changes how the present reads once we are back. A line that sounded brave now sounds like a lie.
So the usual place for a flashback is just after its question. Put it earlier and you are answering something nobody has asked yet.
Two timelines are two stories
Many book-club novels run two timelines side by side: a woman clearing a house today, say, and the woman who lived in it sixty years before. Now the past is not a visit. It is a second story.
The past line: backstory or story?
So each line needs its own question and rising stakes. Its people want something in their own present, and can lose it. If the 1962 chapters exist only to explain the 2019 ones, they are backstory in costume.
And the two lines have to talk to each other. A common link is a secret that one line holds and the other is trying to uncover, so that the reader often knows more than the present-day character. Echoes help too: the same object, place or choice turning up in both. Where the lines finally meet, both questions should be answered, or at least turned.
Keeping both lines alive
Readers of dual-timeline novels sometimes say they skipped one line to get back to the other. That usually means the skipped line had less at stake, or had gone too long without changing. Three habits help.
A clean switch
- Leave on something openThe reader carries it across
- A headingA name, a place or a year
- A detail of that timeIn the first sentence or two
- A texture of its ownNarrator, tense or rhythm
Orient the reader at every switch: a heading with a name, a place or a year, then a detail in the first sentence or two that could belong only to that time. A texture of its own for each line, such as a different narrator, tense or rhythm, helps too.
Switch on a question. Leave each line where something is open, so the reader carries it across the switch. A line left at rest is easy to put down.
Keep both clocks running. The lines need not be equal in length, but each should have moved since the reader last saw it.
Example
One switch, two stories
The end of a present-day chapter and the start of the next. Notice what crosses the switch with the reader.
ELSIE, 2019
The pawn ticket was in the toe of her grandmother’s good shoe, folded in four. Number 4471.1 One gold ring, engraved. Fourteen shillings. The day and month had worn away, but the year had not: 1962.
Elsie shook the shoe in case there was more. A little sand ran out, fine and pale, from a beach her grandmother had always said she had never seen.
On the dresser stood the wedding photograph: Nan in a borrowed hat, her bare left hand on Grandad’s arm, and on it, plain as anything, the ring she had worn until the week she died.
So whose ring had been worth fourteen shillings?2
MAY, 19623
The pawnbroker on Quay Lane did not look up when the bell went, which suited May. She put the ring on the counter and kept her gloves on.
“Engraved,” he said, tipping it to the window. “That knocks it down.”
“Then knock it down.”
He wrote the ticket slowly, the way men did when they wanted you to know they had seen your face. Four, four, seven, one.4 Through the glass she could see the coast bus at the stop with its engine running, and her case beside it, where anyone could take it5.
- “folded in four. Number 4471.”An object with a number on it. The number is about to matter in both timelines.
- “So whose ring had been worth fourteen shillings?”The present line’s question, and the chapter leaves on it. The reader carries it into 1962.
- “MAY, 1962”The switch is labelled with a name and a year, so the reader is placed before the first sentence.
- “Four, four, seven, one.”The echo. The reader recognises the number and now knows something Elsie does not: the past line holds the secret the present is trying to uncover.
- “her case beside it, where anyone could take it”The past line’s own question and its own clock. May is leaving, and the bus will not wait. Her chapter is a story, not only an answer to Elsie’s.
Before and after
The same flashback in two places
The one faultThe flashback comes before the present has raised the question it answers.
Twelve years ago Ines had fitted a safe in rooms above a bakery, for a man who paid in cash and asked for something no customer had asked for before or since: a second keyhole, hidden behind the hinge plate, that opened the door without the code. He watched her cut it. When she had finished he asked her to forget it, and gave her another two hundred for the trouble. She spent it on tyres.
The dead man’s safe was at the back of a wardrobe, behind a rail of suits still in their dry-cleaning bags. Detective Sergeant Okafor held the light.
“Can you open it?”
Ines knelt and ran her thumb along the hinge plate. Three small scratches in a row, low down, where nobody would look. Her scratches.
“Well?” said Okafor.
Ines took her thumb off the plate. “It’ll take a few hours,” she said. “Maybe all night.”
The two versions hold the same sentences in a different order, with “a safe” changed to “that safe herself” to suit.
In the first, the reader gets the hidden keyhole before there is any reason to want it, so when Ines finds the scratches there is nothing left to wonder about.
In the second, the scratches stop her and the reader asks why. The memory answers at the moment she has to decide, so it plays as her thought, not the author’s preface, and her last line lands as a lie that the reader is in on and Okafor is not. The facts are the same. This time the reader asked for them.
The exception
When to break it
Some books open in the past on purpose. A first chapter set years earlier works when it raises a question instead of answering one: a door left open, a child who does not come home.
Not every pair of timelines has to meet in the plot. Some novels set two lives a century apart side by side and let them speak only through echoes. Nor do the lines have to weigh the same. A thin present-day frame round a long story from the past is an old shape, and it works when the frame has a small question of its own.
And a few books leave the reader unsure which time they are in, for a stretch, because that confusion is the point.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Why here?
Halfway through chapter 4, a ferry pilot refuses, without a word of explanation, to take her boat past a certain buoy. Her passengers are furious. The writer has a two-page flashback about that buoy and puts it straight after the refusal. Which is the strongest reason for that placement?
Key takeaway
Place a flashback just after the present has made the reader ask the question it answers, and let it change how the next moment reads. With two timelines, give each line its own question and rising stakes, link them with echoes and secrets, label every switch, and leave each line on something open, so that neither is the one readers skip.
