Three small words
A beat is one event in a story: a thing that happens, or a thing someone does. An outline is a list of beats. This lesson is about what goes between them.
What goes in the gap
Take any two beats that sit next to each other and try a word in the gap. There are three candidates.
“Therefore” means the second beat happens because of the first. She misses the last train, therefore she walks home through the park.
“But” means something gets in the way of the first beat. She walks home through the park, but the gates have been locked for the night.
“And then” means the only link is the clock. She walks home through the park, and then it rains, and then she remembers her aunt.
A story joined by “therefore” and “but” is a chain. A story joined by “and then” is a list. The test is often attributed to the television writers Trey Parker and Matt Stone, who are reported to have described it to a university writing class in 2011. E. M. Forster made a similar distinction in Aspects of the Novel: events told in time order are one thing, and events told so that we see what caused what are another.
What the chain does for a reader
When each beat causes the next, a reader can look ahead. They see a character tell a lie in chapter two and begin to wait for the bill. That waiting is one of the things that makes a book hard to put down.
The thumb test
- Cover one beat with your thumbIn your own outline
- Read onDo the beats after it still make sense?
- If they do, it holds nothing upFind it a cause in what someone did, or cut it
A chain also makes events matter. In a list, a broken oven is bad luck, and it is over by the next beat. In a chain, the broken oven is why she phones the repairman, and the repairman is why everything else happens.
Here is a way to check your own outline. Cover one beat with your thumb and read on. If the beats after it still make sense, the covered beat is not holding anything up.
Notice, too, where the causes come from. The strongest links are things a character chose: a lie, a short cut, a refusal. A link made of weather or coincidence will hold, but the reader can feel the author’s hand in it.
Example
Six beats, five links
An outline for the opening of a fantasy novel. Read it for the joins.
Zahra, a salt carrier, loses her mule to a rockfall on the high pass.
Because she cannot carry the load alone1, she hires a stranger at the next well.
But the stranger is a deserter2, and soldiers hunting for him stop the pair at the river fort.
To get them through, Zahra swears he is her brother3. The captain lets them pass, but he writes both names in the fort’s book.
Her real brother’s name is already in that book, as a soldier of the same garrison. A clerk notices, and riders are sent after them.4
So Zahra leaves the road5, and the salt, and follows the deserter into the marsh.
- “Because she cannot carry the load alone”A “therefore” link. Take away the dead mule and she has no reason to hire anyone.
- “But the stranger is a deserter”A “but” link. It gets in the way of her plan, and it comes out of her own choice of helper. A different stranger would have meant no soldiers.
- “Zahra swears he is her brother”A decision, and the strongest kind of cause. Everything after this is the price of the lie.
- “A clerk notices, and riders are sent after them.”Therefore again. The pursuit exists only because of what she swore and what the captain wrote down.
- “So Zahra leaves the road”The last beat is caused by all five before it. Cover any one with your thumb and she would still be on the road with her salt.
Before and after
One love story, linked two ways
The one faultThe beats are joined only by time. Nothing causes anything.
Ximena opens her bakery on the same day that a café opens across the street.
Then her oven breaks down.
The next week she meets Ruairi, an oven repairman, at a friend’s birthday.
After that, a food writer visits the street.
Then Ruairi asks Ximena to dinner.
Later the café closes, and Ximena and Ruairi kiss outside the bakery.
Both versions tell the same love story through the same events: two openings, a broken oven, a meeting, a food writer, an invitation to dinner, a closure and a kiss.
In the first, try your thumb over any beat. The oven could stay whole, the food writer could stay at home, and the kiss would arrive just the same. The words that open the beats give it away: then, the next week, after that, later.
The second version keeps every one of those events and gives each a reason. The oven breaks because of the price war. She meets Ruairi because of the oven, where the first version used a birthday party that led nowhere. The writer matters because Ruairi mentioned her. To make the reasons work, some joining facts were added: the price war, the nights of baking, the sister’s temper. The main one is that Ruairi is the café owner’s brother. Now cover the oven and the whole romance falls down, which is what you want.
The exception
When to break it
A chain is the usual way to build a plot, and there are good books that do something else.
A coincidence that…
Some stories are episodic on purpose. A road novel, a year in a village or a detective’s casebook may offer a string of adventures, and the pleasure is in each one. Such books tend to be held together by something other than cause: a journey with an end point, a season, a change in the person who lives through the episodes.
Chance has its place too. A coincidence that starts the trouble is easy to accept, since every story has to begin somewhere. A coincidence that ends the trouble tends to feel like a cheat. And a book about war or illness may want one blow that comes from nowhere, because that is what such things are like.
In a novel with several storylines, a beat is often caused by something five beats back and not by its neighbour. Run the test along each line separately.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Chain or list?
Which of these pairs of beats is joined by cause, and not only by time?
Key takeaway
Between each pair of beats, try “therefore”, “but” and “and then”. Keep the first two. Where only “and then” fits, find a reason for the beat in what a character has already done, or ask whether the story needs the beat at all.
