What a set piece is made of
A set piece is the long sequence a reader retells: the escape across the frozen lake, the hour in the locked archive, the wedding where everyone has a gun under the table. It is built around one dangerous situation and held for longer than an ordinary scene, often for a whole chapter or more.
The parts of a set piece
- A place with rulesHow it works, shown before it matters
- An objectiveWhat the lead must do here
- A visible threatWho or what stands against them
- A limitTime, distance or air running out
It has a few working parts, and you can check a plan for each before you write a word.
A place with its own rules. A car deck that is sealed at sea. A cellar that floods at high tide. A vault with one stair. The rules decide what can go wrong and how the lead can get out, and the best ones are shown to the reader before the set piece begins.
An objective: what the lead must do here, concrete enough to succeed or fail at.
A threat the reader can see: a person, a force, a thing that will happen.
And a limit: the time, the distance, the air or the patience that is running out.
Complications in rising order
Once the parts are in place, list everything that could go wrong in this place, given its rules. Then choose three or four and put them in order, so that each is worse than the one before or takes away a way out. Keep the worst for last.
Each one worse
- The planWhat the lead means to do
- A snagA new move gets round it
- WorseA way out is closed
- WorstThe threat arrives, or the limit is reached
- The turnSomething won, something lost
The lead answers every complication with a new move. The plan changes, the route changes, a risk is taken that was not part of the plan. A set piece is a run of small attempts and failures inside one larger one, and the reader is held by watching the lead adapt.
The place does a lot of the work. If the stairs are locked, then needing to leave the deck becomes a complication of its own. Anything you planted about the place earlier (a stuck door, a tide line, a key only one person holds) can be used here, and the reader enjoys seeing it come back.
Example
A set piece, planned
A thriller writer’s plan for the sequence at the centre of her book, written before she drafts it.
The place. The car deck of the morning ferry to the islands. Once the ship is out of the harbour the deck is sealed, and the stairs to it are locked.1 Only the purser has the key. (Planted in chapter 4, when Leah gets locked out of her own car.)2
The objective. Get Sami, aged nine, out of the back of the grey van before the ship docks.
The threat. Harlan, who owns the van, is somewhere on the ship. He has seen Leah’s face once.
The limit. The crossing takes fifty minutes.3 At the far side, the van drives straight off and onto the island road.
Complications, in order.
1. The van is boxed in by a lorry. She can reach the back doors only by crawling under the trailer.
2. The back doors are padlocked. She has to go up and find something to cut the lock, which means leaving the deck and needing the purser to let her down again.
3. The purser is with Harlan in the bar, laughing at something.4
4. When she gets back down, the van’s engine is running.
The turn. She gets Sami out. Harlan sees the van’s open doors in his mirror and does not stop. He knows who she is now, and he still has the other two children.5
- “Once the ship is out of the harbour the deck is sealed, and the st…”The place’s rule, and the source of the third complication.
- “(Planted in chapter 4, when Leah gets locked out of her own car.)”The rule is shown before it matters, in a small moment of its own.
- “The crossing takes fifty minutes.”A limit the reader can feel. Each complication spends some of it.
- “3. The purser is with Harlan in the bar, laughing at something.”The key she needs is beside the threat. The rule of the place and the threat combine.
- “He knows who she is now, and he still has the other two children.”The turn. She wins Sami and loses her cover, and the book is now a different kind of chase.
End on a turn, and slow down inside
A set piece should leave the story changed. The lead gets what they came for and loses something on the way: a cover, an ally, a way home. Or they fail, and learn something that changes what they do next. If they simply escape and the next chapter goes on as before, the sequence was exciting and spent.
Inside the set piece, time slows. Moments that would be a sentence elsewhere get a paragraph: the padlock, the engine starting, the face in the mirror. Short sentences carry the peaks, but keep it clear where everyone is. Around it, give the reader room. A quieter scene before lets you show the place and its rules; a quieter scene after lets the cost land.
Before and after
The same snags, in two orders
The one faultThe complications get smaller instead of larger.
Objective: take the iron seal from the vault beneath the Bell Temple before the noon bell, when the priests come down.
1. The high priest himself walks in and finds them at the open vault. 2. The ward on the vault door takes longer to unpick than Teo said it would. 3. Mira’s lantern gutters out and they have to work by the light from the grating. 4. A novice comes down the far stair, sweeping, and they have to wait in the dark for him to pass.
Both plans have the same objective, the same limit and the same four complications. Only the order has changed.
In the first, the worst thing that can happen (the high priest finding them) happens first. After that, a slow ward, a lantern and a sweeping novice are a let-down. Worse, once they have been caught at the vault, why are they still unpicking its ward?
In the second, each problem is a step up. Bad light, then a near miss, then the ward eating into the time, then the one man who must not find them. The reader’s worry climbs with every step, and the sequence ends at its highest point.
The exception
When to break it
Not every book needs a set piece. A quiet psychological thriller may build its suspense from conversations and silences, and a showpiece sequence could break its spell.
Some set pieces deliberately start at the top. A sequence can open with the worst already happening (the plane is going down) and draw its tension from what the lead can save. Even then, the complications inside it usually rise: the first engine, then the second, then the fuel.
And a comic set piece in a cosy mystery may end with nothing much changed except everyone’s dignity. That can be the right payment for that book, so long as the reader came for the fun of it.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Exciting and forgettable
A thriller’s set piece: after closing time, the lead must take a letter from a museum display case before the guard’s round. The case alarm will not switch off, the guard comes early, and her accomplice’s phone rings. She gets the letter, slips out, and the next chapter opens with her reading it at home, as planned. Early readers say it was exciting and forgettable. Which change would help most?
Key takeaway
Build a set piece from a place with rules, an objective, a visible threat and a limit, and show the place before it matters. Order the complications so each is worse than the last, let the lead answer each one, and end on a turn that leaves the story changed.
