Who gets the fact first?
Every scene has one fact that matters more than the rest. The bank is closing the shop. The tuner knows the house. There is something in the soup. Before you write the scene, it is worth deciding who gets that fact first: the character or the reader.
Where the reader stands
- BehindWhat is going on?
- LevelWhat will happen next?
- Ahead: dramatic ironyWhen will she find out, and what will it cost?
There are three places the reader can stand. Behind the character: she knows something we do not, and the question in our minds is what is going on. Level with the character: we find out together, and the question is what will happen next. Ahead of the character: we know and she does not. This last position is called dramatic irony, and the question it raises is the most uncomfortable of the three. When will she find out, and what will it cost her?
The same events can be told from any of the three positions. What changes is the question the reader carries through the scene.
Order is the tool
You control the reader’s position through order. Whatever you tell them first, they know while they read everything after it.
Order is the tool
- Tell the reader firstA letter in a man’s jacket
- Then the ordinary talkHis wife on paint colours
- We hear it differentlyShe has not changed a word
Putting the reader ahead does something useful to ordinary dialogue. Once we know about the letter in a man’s jacket, his wife’s talk about paint colours is no longer small talk. She has not changed a word. We have changed what we hear.
Information control goes wrong in three common ways. The first is telling everything at once, so that no question forms. The second is the leak: a narrator who cannot resist announcing what is about to happen (“as she would soon discover”) and spends the scene’s question before the scene has started. The third is the cheat. If the story is told closely through one character, and that character sees who is at the door, the reader expects to see it too. “She opened the door and stared at the last person she expected” hides nothing from her. It only covers the reader’s eyes, and readers tend to notice the hand.
Example
The reader ahead
A couple who mend shoes for a living talk about painting the front of their shop. One fact, placed in the first paragraph, changes every line that follows.
Eamon read the letter from the bank twice in the alley behind the shop, folded it in four and put it inside his jacket. Sixty days.1 Then he went in through the back and washed his hands.2
Lottie was at the front counter with a fan of paint cards.
“For the front of the shop,” she said. “I thought yellow. A serious yellow, not a lemon.”
“Yellow’s good.”3
“You’re not looking.” She held two cards against the window frame, one above the other. “This one’s called Harvest. This one’s called Old Gold, which I think is the same paint at a higher price.”
He looked. “Harvest.”
“We can’t do it till spring anyway. Not till the new stitcher’s paid off.” She tucked the card into the edge of the till, where she would see it every day4. “Something to look forward to.”
“Something to look forward to,” Eamon said, and patted his jacket flat5.
- “Sixty days.”The fact that matters, given to the reader first and in two words. We are not told what the letter says in full, and we do not need to be.
- “Then he went in through the back and washed his hands.”He has decided not to tell her yet. From this sentence on, the reader knows something Lottie does not.
- ““Yellow’s good.””An ordinary line that now has weight on it. He is agreeing to a colour for a shop he may not have.
- “where she would see it every day”A detail that only hurts because of what we know. To Lottie it is a pleasant plan.
- “patted his jacket flat”A reminder of where the letter is, with no need to mention the letter.
The explainer
Keep the panel a secret
Mrs Varley’s hall, and the first version of the scene. Only the opening needs changing. Press a sentence to swap in its rewrite, and watch the secret wait in the wall until the tuner gives it away himself.

Changes left
3 of 3
Words
198 (was 198)
Press a sentence to make its change and watch the room.
Before and after
One sentence too many
The one faultThe narrator announces the secret, and how it is about to come out, before the scene has raised the question.
The piano tuner came on Wednesdays, with a boy to carry his bag, though he knew the house better than the family did, and a hidden door was about to prove it to Constable Stannard. She waited in the hall while he worked, listening to one note struck over and over.
“You were here the afternoon the bracelet went,” she said, when he stopped.
“I was. I heard Mrs Varley go up, and I heard her come down. But I never set foot outside this room. I couldn’t find my way to her stairs, let alone her jewel box.” He closed the lid and put the tuning fork back in its case.
“Mrs Varley asks if you’d leave by the side door today. They’re scrubbing the front step.”
“Of course.”
He picked up his bag and went past her into the hall. He did not look about for the side door. He turned left at once, to the panel under the stairs that was papered to match the wall, and put his hand flat on the place where it opened.
Neither of them spoke. He held the door for her, quite politely, as if she were the visitor.
The two versions differ only in their opening. In the first, the narrator announces straight away that the tuner knows the house, that the constable is about to find out, and how. That answers every question the scene could have run on: what is this man hiding, will she catch him, and by what means? When he walks straight to the hidden door, the reader is only watching a promise being kept.
The early telling does buy one thing: his line about never leaving the room now reads as a lie, a small piece of dramatic irony. Putting the reader ahead is not wrong in itself, and the scene could be rebuilt to use it, with the constable setting traps. But here the narrator has told us the outcome as well, so there is nothing left to wait for.
As written, the scene is built as a discovery. In the second version the reader makes that discovery at the same moment the constable does, and from the same evidence: a man who went straight to a door he had no way of knowing was there.
The exception
When to break it
A narrator who holds something back can be the whole design of a book. It tends to work when the silence belongs to the character: a first-person narrator who is ashamed, or lying to themselves, or telling the story to someone they want to impress. The reader should be able to look back and find that the clues were there.
Holding back by design
Stories about heists and schemes often hide the plan from the reader even though every character knows it, because watching a plan we have already heard go smoothly can be dull. In that kind of story, the plan the reader hears in full is often the one that goes wrong.
Some books give away the ending on the first page. That swaps the question of what happened for the question of how. And some scenes should carry no hidden information at all. After a long stretch of secrets, a scene in which everyone, reader included, knows everything can be a relief.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Where is the reader standing?
In which of these is the reader ahead of Signe, so that the scene runs on dramatic irony?
Key takeaway
For each fact that matters, decide whether the reader learns it before the character, with them, or after. Each position raises a different question. Then put the facts in the order that opens that question early and keeps it open, without hiding anything by a trick.
