Two different jobs
An autobiography sets out to tell a whole life. It starts at or near birth, moves forward in order, and tries to leave out nothing important. Its organising tool is the calendar.
Two different jobs
A memoir does a smaller and stranger job. It takes one part of a life (a year, a job, a marriage, a house) and asks what that part meant. Its organising tool is a question.
The two words are often used loosely. The difference still matters to you as a writer, because it changes what goes in. In an autobiography your first day at school belongs in the book because it happened. In a memoir it belongs only if it helps to answer the question.
Three decisions
Before you write very much, try to make three decisions. You can change them later, and plenty of writers do.
- The periodFrom the move to the farm to its sale
- The questionWhy was the front step left broken?
- What you leave outSay plainly what stays outside the fence
The period. Where does the book start and where does it stop? “My childhood” is vague. “From the day we moved to the farm to the day it was sold” is a period.
The question. What are you trying to find out? A topic is not a question. “My father” is a topic. “Why did my father, who could mend anything, leave the front step broken for twenty years?” is a question, and a reader will keep reading to hear the answer. You do not need to know the answer when you begin.
What you leave out. Most of your life will not be in this book. That is hard to accept, because all of it happened to you. Saying plainly what stays outside the fence makes the rest easier to write.
Example
All three, on one page
This is the opening of an invented memoir, written for this lesson. Watch for the period, the question and what is left out.
From the March my aunt flew to Lahore until the February she came back1, I ran her fabric shop on Cutler Row. Eleven months. I was thirty-four and had never sold anything to anyone.
This book is about those months and nothing else. I had a husband by then, and a small daughter, and they are in these pages only when they came into the shop2. My years at the tax office are not here at all.3 Neither is my aunt’s own story, which is hers, and longer and better than mine.
What I want to know is easy to ask. Before that spring I would have told you, without being asked, that I was not a shop person. I said it at weddings. I said it to my aunt’s face. By the autumn I could cut four metres of lining by eye and tell a customer, kindly, that the green was wrong for her. So who had I been describing, all those years, and why was I so sure of her?4
- “From the March my aunt flew to Lahore until the February she came back”The period. It has a first day and a last day, and both are events, so the writer will know whether any memory falls inside.
- “they are in these pages only when they came into the shop”A test for what gets in. Her family matters to her more than the shop did, but this book is about the shop.
- “My years at the tax office are not here at all.”What is left out, said plainly. Sixteen years are set aside in one sentence.
- “So who had I been describing, all those years, and why was I so su…”The question. It is hers alone, it is open, and the eleven months are the evidence she will use to answer it.
Example
A long span, one strand
A memoir does not have to be short in years. This one, also invented, covers three decades.
For thirty-one years1 my father rang me on Sunday at six, his time, whatever time that made it for me. This is a book about those calls. It runs from the first one, to a payphone in a student hall, to the last, which I took in a parked car with the engine running. Whole decades of my life happened between Sundays and are not in it. My work is not in it. Most of my friends are not. I have kept only what was said on the line2, and what I did in the minute after I put the phone down.
- “For thirty-one years”Far longer than the shop book. What keeps it a memoir is that it follows one strand of those years and lets the rest go.
- “I have kept only what was said on the line”Here the fence is drawn round a strand, not round dates. Anything that did not happen on a Sunday call, or just after one, stays out.
Before and after
The same book, begun two ways
The one faultThe chapter starts at birth and walks forward through the whole life before it reaches the period the book is about.
I was born in the winter of 1975, the second of three girls, in rooms above a dry cleaner’s. My father drove a delivery van and my mother took in alterations. I started school at five and did well at arithmetic. At eleven I went to the girls’ school across the river, where I was happy enough. I left at eighteen, took a clerk’s post at the tax office, and stayed for sixteen years. I married at twenty-nine. Our daughter was born two years later. Then, in the March I was thirty-four, my aunt flew to Lahore and asked me to mind her fabric shop on Cutler Row until she came back.
Both versions are plainly written and both end up in the shop. The first does not reach the shop until its eighth sentence, because it is following the calendar: birth, school, work, marriage, child. Each fact is true and none of them has been chosen.
The second starts on the first day of the eleven months. It keeps three things from the earlier life: the tax office, the mother’s alterations, the husband and child. Each is there because the shop months need it. The clerk who has never sold anything is the person the question is about, and the alterations are the only training she has. The dry cleaner’s, the arithmetic and the school across the river have gone, and the book loses nothing.
The exception
When to break it
Sometimes the whole life is the right book. If you are writing a record for your family, they may want every house and every job in order, and a question would only get in the way. A long public career can carry an autobiography too, when the full account is the point.
When the fence bends
The fence also has gates. A memory from outside the period can come in when the question needs it: a book about one year in a shop may need one afternoon from childhood. The test is the question, not the date.
And you do not have to wait for a perfect question before you start. Some writers find theirs only in a second draft. A rough one is enough to begin choosing with, and it can be replaced.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which plan is a memoir?
Five people describe the book they plan to write. Which plan is a memoir in the sense this lesson uses?
Key takeaway
An autobiography is organised by the calendar and a memoir by a question. Choose a period or a single strand, say what you are trying to find out, and name what stays outside. Then let in only what the question needs.
