Lesson 1 of 9
Seedling Hill · stone 1Foundation5 minute read

Part of: Creative Writing for Beginners, module 2 (Finding your story)

What-if generation

Turning something you noticed into a story-sized question by asking “what if?”

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

Seedling Hill: a single young tree on a round hill, being watered by a small figure.
Seedling Hill · Idea and premise, stone 1 of 9

Start with something you noticed

A story idea rarely arrives whole. More often it starts with something small that a writer happened to notice: a single glove left on a bus seat, a neighbour who waters her garden at three in the morning, a shop that has had a “closing down” sign in the window for years.

On its own an observation is not a story; a what-if about it is the start of one.

That noticed thing is an observation. On its own it is not a story. It becomes the start of one when you ask a question about it, and the most useful question begins with two words: what if?

A what-if takes the thing you noticed, changes it or pushes it further, and asks what would follow. What if the glove was left there on purpose? What if the garden only grows in the dark? You do not need a clever idea to begin. You need something you noticed and a willingness to ask a silly question about it.

From a situation to a story

Most first what-ifs describe a situation, which is an odd state of affairs. “What if lost gloves found their own way home?” is charming, and nothing in it has to happen next. Nobody is in it.

A particular person, a pressure and an open question turn a situation into something story-sized.

Three additions turn a situation into something the size of a story.

A person. Not people in general, but one particular someone, placed close to the odd thing. A bus driver keeps every glove left on her bus.

A pressure. This is anything that means she cannot simply carry on as before: a want, a threat or a deadline. One of the gloves has a wedding ring inside it, and the man who comes asking for it is not the man who lost it.

An open question. This is something the reader wants to find out and cannot guess. Does she hand it over?

Now there is someone to follow, a reason they have to act, and an outcome we cannot see yet. That is what “story-sized” means in this lesson.

Example

One idea, grown on the page

A writer has asked a what-if about a town clock and kept going. Watch for the moment a person walks in.

The clock at Varnayfantasy

What if a town’s clock could be bribed?1

In Varnay the clock in the square runs fast for anyone who leaves a coin on its ledge. Bakers pay it to bring the morning on. The whole town knows, and nobody says so.

Frieda Solberg is seventeen and winds the clock for a wage.2 On the morning her brother is due to hang at noon3, she climbs the tower with every coin she owns tied in her apron. She means to buy him one more hour. Nobody has ever paid the clock to run slow, and she does not know what it charges4.

  1. “What if a town’s clock could be bribed?”The bare what-if. It is a situation: interesting, and nobody has to do anything about it yet.
  2. “Frieda Solberg is seventeen and winds the clock for a wage.”A person, and one placed as close to the odd thing as anyone could be. She has a name, an age and a job.
  3. “On the morning her brother is due to hang at noon”The pressure. There is a deadline, and someone she will lose when it comes. She cannot wait until next week.
  4. “she does not know what it charges”The open question. Will the clock take her coins, and what will it ask for? We cannot guess, so we want to read on.

Before and after

The same what-if, stopped early and carried on

The one faultThe idea stays a situation: no particular person is under pressure in it.

Weaker versionNo more sleep (first version)

What if people stopped needing sleep? A treatment comes on the market that removes the need for it. Within ten years most adults have taken it. Cities stay lit all night, shops never shut, and the working day stretches to fill the hours.

Beds become antiques. Night buses run as full as morning ones. Children are the only people who still dream, and they grow out of it.

Showing the weaker version.

Both versions begin with the same question and the same invented treatment, and both are clearly written.

The first goes wide. It tells us what happens to cities, shops, beds and buses, and it could go on listing changes for pages. It is a setting. Nobody in it has to do anything by any particular day, so there is nothing to wait for.

The second keeps the opening paragraph word for word and then narrows to one man. Fergus Dolan drives a night bus. He has until the end of the month. Taking the treatment has a cost and so does refusing it, and we do not know which he will choose.

The invented world is the same in both. What the second version adds is someone standing in it with a decision to make.

The exception

When to break it

The three additions are a test for when an idea is ready to be written. They are not a test for whether an idea is allowed into your notebook. When you are making a list of what-ifs, write the bare ones down too. Judging each line as it arrives is a quick way to stop having them.

The three additions test whether an idea is ready to be written, not whether it may go in your notebook.

Plenty of writers start from a world or a situation and find the person later, sometimes weeks later. That is a normal order of work. The search for a person just needs to happen before the drafting does, or the draft tends to wander.

Some stories do lean on the situation and keep the person light: fables, very short stories built on one strange turn, and some science fiction in which the changed world is the main attraction. Even there, it helps to show the change landing on somebody.

And the words “what if” are not magic. “Suppose”, “imagine” or a plain statement will do the same job.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 1 min

Which one is story-sized?

Which of these what-ifs already has all three: a particular person, something pressing on them, and an open question?

Key takeaway

Begin with something you noticed and ask “what if?” about it. Then look for three things in the idea: a particular person, something pressing on them, and a question you cannot answer yet. Whichever one is missing is the next thing to invent.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Try it on your own pages

Choose a passage from your own book where this matters: what-if generation. Read it against the checklist, then revise the weakest part.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.