One change
A short story is not a small novel. It does a different job. Most short stories follow one person through one change: by the end, something about them, or about where they stand, is different in a way that matters. The story is the shortest good route from before to after.
The shape of a short story
- At the startOne person, as they are
- The pressureSomething they cannot ignore
- At the endDifferent in one way that matters
The change can be large or very small. A soldier deserts. A girl stops waiting for a letter. A man admits, to himself and nobody else, that he was wrong. What matters is that there is one of it, so that every scene can lean towards it.
One pressure, and room for little else
Something has to push the change. Call it the pressure: a problem, a want or a threat the person cannot put down. In a short story there is usually one, and the story keeps coming back to it.
- The castOne or two people who matter
- The timeAn afternoon, a night or a week
- The pastTold in a line, not a chapter
- Side threadsCut, or left as background
Because there is room for so little, a short story compresses. It keeps the cast to one or two people who matter, and the time to an afternoon, a night or a week. It tells the past in a line instead of a chapter. A good test for any scene, character or memory is to ask whether the change needs it. If it does not, it probably belongs in another story.
How short is short?
Length is the last thing to decide, not the first, but it helps to know the bands. One widely used set, from the Nebula Awards run by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers Association, calls anything under 7,500 words a short story. From 7,500 to just under 17,500 words is a novelette, from 17,500 to just under 40,000 a novella, and 40,000 or more a novel.
What a finished piece is called
- Short storyUnder 7,500
- NoveletteIn between
- Novella17,500 to just under 40,000
- Novel40,000 or more
Other awards and magazines draw their lines in other places, and each one publishes its own limits. For a first story, aim for something you can finish: between 1,500 and 4,000 words is plenty of room for one change.
Example
One drive, one change
A whole short story, under three hundred words. Watch how little it needs.
Nadia’s father had promised to teach her to drive for three summers running, and for three summers the car had stayed in the garage under a sheet1. Now he sat in the passenger seat with his arms folded.
“Mirror,” he said. “Signal. You know this.”
She knew it. She pulled out of the close at eleven miles an hour, and he said nothing about the speed, which was how she knew he was frightened.
At the junction by the school a delivery van had stopped across both lanes. Nadia waited. The van did not move. Behind her someone sounded a horn, long and flat, and her father’s hand came off his knee and hovered near the handbrake2.
“I’ve got it,” she said.
“I know.”
“Then put your hand down.”3
He looked at his hand as if it belonged to someone else, and put it in his lap. Nadia checked the mirror, signalled, and took the car round the van with a foot to spare. Neither of them breathed until they were past the bakery.
At the next red light he unfolded his arms. He did not say well done. He said, “Left here, and I’ll show you the coast road,” and she understood that the lessons would end soon, and that this was what he had been afraid of all along4.
- “for three summers the car had stayed in the garage under a sheet”Three years of history in one clause. The story compresses the past and spends its words on the present.
- “her father’s hand came off his knee and hovered near the handbrake”The pressure, as one small thing we can see. Nothing else in the story competes with it.
- ““Then put your hand down.””The turn. She asks for the one thing the story is about: to be trusted with the car.
- “this was what he had been afraid of all along”The change lands in the last line. The drive has changed where the two of them stand, and we know why.
Before and after
The same idea, planned twice
The one faultThree side threads compete with the one change the story is about.
About 4,000 words. Tamsin, a ferryman’s daughter, has to row a dying witch across the river before dawn, because the witch has promised to lift the curse on the village if she reaches the far bank.
On the way Tamsin falls in love with the witch’s apprentice, finds out that her own mother was once a witch, and starts a feud with the miller over the price of the crossing.
It ends with the witch on the far bank, the curse lifted, the apprentice gone home, the miller paid, and Tamsin deciding to study magic herself.
Both plans start from the same crossing, the same witch and the same promise, and both are clear.
The first adds a love story, a family secret and a feud. Each of those is a change of its own, with a beginning, a middle and an end to pay for. In 4,000 words each would get a paragraph, and the ending has to tie off five things at once.
The second keeps the crossing and presses harder on it. The witch’s request turns the trip into a choice, and the story ends when Tamsin makes it. The apprentice, the mother and the miller are not wrong. They are another story, or a longer one.
The exception
When to break it
Plenty of fine short stories bend this shape. In some, the person does not change at all, and the change happens in the reader, who understands something the character never will. Some very short pieces, often called flash fiction, are a single moment with the change only hinted at. A story can even cover many years if it tells most of them in summary and still turns only once.
Other shapes that work
And some ideas are simply bigger than a short story. If yours keeps growing new threads that each need an ending, it may be a novella or a novel trying to get out. That is useful to know, not a failure. For a first story, though, pick the idea with one change in it, because that is the one you can finish.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Shaped like a short story
Which of these ideas is already shaped like a short story: one person, one pressure, one change?
Key takeaway
A short story follows one person through one change, pushed by one pressure. Keep the cast, the time and the past small, and cut whatever the change does not need. Decide the length last; for a first story, 1,500 to 4,000 words is room enough.
