Where does the next scene come from?
Thirty thousand words in, the premise has been delivered. The reader knows who the story is about and what they are after, and you are facing the question that waits in the middle of most novels: what happens now? If the only answer is “whatever I can think of”, the book has a premise and no engine.
A Christmas Carol’s engine
- The first spiritThe past: regret
- The secondThe present: loss
- The thirdThe future: the grave
- Morning comesThe visits run out: an ending
A story engine is a rule built into the set-up that keeps producing scenes of the same kind. The phrase is common in talk about television, where a series needs something that can turn out an episode every week. John Truby, in The Anatomy of Story, describes a close relative under the name “designing principle”: the organising idea that gives a premise its particular shape.
Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol is a clear case. Its premise is that a miser is frightened into kindness. Its engine is that three spirits visit him in one night, and each shows him a different time. From that one rule come the main scenes, their order, their rising pressure as the visions move from regret to loss to the grave, and an ending, because the visits run out when morning comes.
Common shapes
Engines come in a few recurring shapes.
- A set to work throughSeven letters, twelve tasks, a list of names
- A clockThirty days, one night, a pregnancy
- A route with stationsA river, a concert tour, a walk across a country
- A ritual that returnsA weekly dinner, an annual holiday
- A rule with a priceEvery wish granted is taken from somebody else
A set to work through: seven letters, twelve tasks, a list of names.
A clock: thirty days, one night, a pregnancy.
A route with stations: a river, a concert tour, a walk across a country.
A ritual that returns: a weekly dinner, an annual holiday.
A rule with a price: every wish she is granted is taken from somebody else.
In the frame story of the Arabian Nights, a queen tells the king a tale each night and breaks off before the end, so that he lets her live to hear the rest. That is a ritual and a rule with a price at once.
Three tests, and the usual cost
Can you state it as a rule? A theme says what the story means. A plot summary says what happens once. An engine says what keeps happening.
Three tests
- State it as a ruleNot what it means, or what happens once: what keeps happening
- List five scenesWithout inventing anything new
- Does each use cost more?An engine that runs down gives an ending
Given the rule, can you list five scenes without inventing anything new? If each scene is the rule applied again in fresh circumstances, the engine is doing the work.
Does each use cost more, or leave fewer to go? An engine that could turn for ever at the same price gives a story that stops when the writer is tired. One that runs down or grows dearer gives an ending.
The cost of a strong engine is that the reader learns the pattern. By the third visit they know a fourth is coming. Writers handle this by changing the outcome each time, by breaking the pattern once where it will be felt, and by making sure that what escalates is the pressure on the character and not merely the size of the incident.
Example
An engine on one page
A plan for a mystery. The premise is ordinary. Watch what the engine line adds to it.
Premise: a probate clerk has to find the rightful heir to a house before the council seizes it at the end of the quarter.
Engine: the dead woman left seven sealed letters, each addressed to a different person1. To learn who should inherit, the clerk delivers them one at a time2, and each person will say what their letter contains only in exchange for something the clerk has to give up3.
What it produces: seven visits. The first costs him an afternoon. The fourth costs him a confidence he was trusted with. By the sixth he has nothing left to trade but the house file itself, and the seventh letter is addressed to him4.
- “seven sealed letters, each addressed to a different person”A set to work through. The reader can count how many are left, which gives the middle of the book a visible shape.
- “delivers them one at a time”The repeatable action. Every delivery is a scene of the same kind with a new person in it.
- “only in exchange for something the clerk has to give up”The price. This clause is what turns a row of interviews into an engine, because each use can cost more than the one before.
- “the seventh letter is addressed to him”The pattern breaks on its final use. The last delivery cannot go like the other six, and the ending comes out of that difference.
Before and after
One premise, two engine lines
The one faultThe engine line states a theme, so nothing in it produces scenes.
Premise: two rival florists share a wall, a delivery van and a grudge.
Engine: the story explores how pride keeps people from what they want, and how forgiveness has to be chosen more than once.
Scenes: they argue about the van; a customer mixes up their orders; her father falls ill; he enters a competition; they are snowed in at the flower market.
The premise is the same in both plans, and it is a good one. Look at the engine lines.
The first says what the story is about underneath: pride and forgiveness. That may well be true of the finished book, but it is a theme. Ask it “what happens next Saturday?” and it has no answer. So the scene list is five separate inventions. Each is plausible, none leads to the next, and the writer will have to think of a sixth from nothing.
The second is a rule: every wedding order, jointly, every Saturday. Ask it the same question and it answers at once. Its scenes are the rule applied five times in different circumstances. It also carries a limit. September ends, and the final scene comes from the engine stopping.
The scene lists differ because the engines differ. The pride and the forgiveness have not gone anywhere. They are what the Saturdays will be about.
The exception
When to break it
Plenty of good novels have no engine you could put in a sentence. If a protagonist is chasing a goal against opposition that keeps escalating, the pursuit produces the scenes, and a mechanism laid on top would be a gimmick. Short stories rarely need one at all.
When the engine steps aside
Engines earn their keep where a middle would otherwise be loose: road stories, investigations made of interviews, romances that need a reason to keep two people in the same room, anything episodic, and series.
An engine can also hand over. The countdown ends early and a pursuit begins, or the list is abandoned at number five. That can be the strongest moment in a book, as long as the reader sees the first engine stop and the second start.
When the character’s change calls for a scene the pattern cannot supply, write the scene and break the pattern. The engine is there to serve the story.
Last, you may not find the engine until a draft exists. Look at your best scenes and ask what they have in common.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which one is an engine?
Four statements about a novel in which a disgraced chef tries to rebuild her career. Which one is a story engine?
Key takeaway
A premise says what the story is. An engine is a rule in the set-up that says where the next scene comes from. Test it three ways. Can it be stated as a rule? Does it give you five scenes without new invention? Does each use cost more or leave fewer to go?
