The whole book, in small
Romantic comedy has a name for a charming first meeting: the meet-cute. In a romance the first meeting does more than charm. It is the scene where the reader decides whether they want these two together, and it sets the terms for everything that follows.
What a first meeting carries
- The pullSomething the other does that the lead cannot help noticing
- The frictionSomething they do that grates, threatens or offends
- The book in smallA small version of what will keep them apart
A strong first meeting usually carries three things. A pull: something the other person does, not just how they look, that the lead cannot help noticing. A friction: something they do that grates, threatens or offends. And the book in small: the thing the two clash over in this scene is a small version of what will stand between them for the whole book.
When all three are there, the reader finishes the scene knowing both why these two should be together and why it will not be easy. That is the question a romance runs on, and the first meeting is where it is asked.
A meeting only these two could have
The spilled coffee, the collision in the corridor, the wrong seat on the train: these can bring any two people together, and that is their weakness. The accident does the work, and the reader learns nothing about either person from it.
Accident or collision of wants
A meeting that comes from what each of them wants does more. She is picking the lock of the archive; he guards it. He has bought the boatyard; she is the one still working in it. The circumstance is the conflict, so the meeting cannot help being about something.
Where you put it matters too. In many romances the leads meet in the first chapter or two, because the reader has come for the pair. If they meet later, give the reader a reason to look forward to it: each lead’s life shown with the gap the other will fill or threaten. In a second-chance romance the scene that counts is the meeting again, years on, where each sees what the other has become.
Example
A first meeting with all three
In this opening scene from a romance, a boatbuilder meets the man who has bought her yard. Watch for the pull, the friction and the book in small.
The man in the good coat had been standing in the doorway of the shed for a full minute before Maud noticed him, and by then the plank was ready and she had no time to be polite.
“You. Take that end.”
He took it. He did not ask why, or look at his coat.1 When she said bend, he bent the hot oak in with her, slowly, the way you would if you had done it before, and held it against the ribs while she clamped.
“She’s a Loch Fyne skiff,” he said, when it was done. “Built before the war, by the look of the stem.”
Maud wiped her hands and looked at him properly. Grey eyes, and a carpenter’s hands under the good cuffs. Nobody who came down this lane knew what a skiff was.2
“Who are you?”
“Callum Reid.” He took a tape measure from his pocket. “I’ve bought the yard. I need the length of this shed for the architects.3”
The clamp was still in her hand. She thought about what it would weigh, thrown.
“The shed,” she said, “is forty feet long, and it’s staying.”
“The shed,” said Callum, measuring it anyway, “is coming down in March. But I’d like to see her in the water first.4”
- “He took it. He did not ask why, or look at his coat.”The first pull is an action. He helps without fuss, which is exactly what Maud values.
- “Nobody who came down this lane knew what a skiff was.”A second pull, and a particular one: he knows her world.
- “I’ve bought the yard. I need the length of this shed for the archi…”The friction arrives after the pull, which makes it land harder.
- “is coming down in March. But I’d like to see her in the water first.”The book in small: he means to replace, she means to keep. His last words hint that he is not only the developer he seems.
Before and after
My road or my door
The one faultThe meeting is a generic accident that could join any two people.
Ilse was hurrying through the market with her head down when she walked straight into him, and his basket of quinces went everywhere.
“Watch what you’re doing,” said the man, picking them out of the gutter.
“You were standing in the way.”
He straightened. He wore the grey cloak of the Archive, and he had a face that had not smiled in some years.
“I was,” he said. “I stand where I like. It’s my road.”
The dialogue is the same in both, and the archivist is the same unsmiling man. In the first, Ilse bumps into him in a market. The friction is real but it is about nothing: any two people could collide over a basket of quinces, and nothing in the scene points forward.
In the second, she is breaking into the place he guards. The same lines now carry the whole book: she wants in, he keeps people out, and ‘It’s my door’ is a statement of who he is. The reader also learns something about Ilse without being told, and wants to know what is behind that door.
The exception
When to break it
Some romances begin after the meeting. Friends who become lovers, a married couple in trouble, two people reunited after years: the scene that does the first meeting’s work is the moment one of them sees the other freshly, as if for the first time. Give that scene the pull, the friction and the book in small instead.
A meeting can also be all warmth, with the friction kept inside one lead rather than between them. A widow who likes the new neighbour at once, and hates herself for it, has friction enough.
And a comic accident can still work, so long as what the two do next comes from who they are. The spilled coffee is not the meeting; the way each of them handles it is.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which meeting sets up the book?
A historical romance will turn on one question: can a woman who has built her own business marry without handing it to her husband, as the law of her time required? Which first meeting best sets that up?
Key takeaway
Make the first meeting carry a pull, a friction and a small version of the conflict that will keep the two apart. Let it come from what each of them wants, so that it could only happen to these two.
