Books by the reader’s age
Books for children are sorted by the age of their reader. The names of the bands vary, but three broad kinds are easy to tell apart by how they are read.
Three kinds, by how they are read
- Picture bookRead by an adult; the pictures carry part of the story
- First chapter bookShort sentences, concrete words, each chapter a small win
- Middle gradeFull plots, room for more than one thread
A picture book is usually read aloud by an adult to a child who cannot yet read alone. The pictures carry part of the story, and the words are written for the ear.
A first chapter book is for a child who has just begun to read alone. Sentences are short, words are concrete and each chapter is a small win.
Middle grade is for confident readers who are not yet teenagers. It has full plots, longer sentences and room for more than one thread.
This lesson gives no ages or lengths. Publishers set their own for each band, and their figures differ and change. Look up the current guidelines of the publisher you are writing for. What stays steady is the idea behind the bands: the language, and the things the story cares about, should fit the child holding the book.
The child solves it
One convention runs through all the bands. The child at the centre of the story is the one who solves its problem.
Whose turning point
- NoticesWhat the grown-ups missed
- DecidesThe idea and the decision are the child’s
- Takes the first stepAdults can do what no child safely could
One reason lies in who is reading. A child spends the day being told what to do by people twice their size. A story in which someone their own age notices what the grown-ups missed, decides and acts offers something they do not often get.
This does not mean the adults are fools or absent. They can be busy, wrong, kind or in the way, and they can do the parts no child safely could. What they do not do is the turning point. The idea, the decision and the first step belong to the child.
Solutions tend to convince most when they use what a child has that adults lack. Children know the hiding places. They are small enough to see under things. They are often not being watched. Sometimes they caused the problem and are the only ones who know it. Build the answer out of that, and the ending will belong to your main character.
Example
The only person not on the phone
This is from a middle-grade story set in a block of flats. Count the adults, and notice where the boy’s knowledge comes from.
The lift had stopped between three and four with Mrs Okoye in it, and every grown-up on the landing was on the phone1.
Dad was on hold with the council. The man from 3B was shouting at an engineer. Auntie kept pressing the button, as if the lift had not noticed.
Wiremu looked at the little steel door beside the lift, the one with the yellow sticker. He knew that door. Every Saturday the caretaker opened it with a key he kept on a hook inside the bin store, behind the fire bucket, because he could never find it otherwise. Wiremu knew because the bin store was the goal when they played football2.
Nobody was looking at him. He went down the stairs two at a time.3
When he came back up, out of breath, he did not try the key himself4. He held it up in front of Dad’s phone until Dad stopped talking.
- “every grown-up on the landing was on the phone”The adults are present and doing sensible things. They are not villains or fools. They are simply looking in the wrong direction.
- “the bin store was the goal when they played football”He knows where the key is because of a game. No adult on the landing could know it in that way.
- “He went down the stairs two at a time.”The decision and the action are his, and nobody sent him. The sentence is short and all its words are plain.
- “he did not try the key himself”The story stays honest about what a boy should do with a lift. He brings the answer and makes an adult look at it, which is still his win.
Before and after
Who fetches the cup
The one faultAn adult works out the answer and carries it out.
The well had been dry for three days when Pema went to look down it.
Something small and green was sitting on the bottom with its arms folded. It had the face of a frog and the temper of her brother.
“Go away,” it said.
Pema went and fetched her grandmother, who knew about such things. Grandmother leaned over the wall and looked for a long moment. “Ah,” she said. “Somebody has taken its cup.” She went straight to the washhouse, found the little horn cup that had hung on the well since before she was born, rinsed it, and hung it back on its nail.
By supper the bucket came up full.
“There,” said Grandmother. “You see how it’s done.”
The two versions share an opening and a well with something cross at the bottom of it. In the first, Pema fetches her grandmother, and from then on every verb is Grandmother’s: she leans, looks, speaks, goes, finds, rinses and hangs. Pema has become a messenger in her own story. The last line even has the adult explain that this was a lesson.
In the second version Pema stays. She notices the empty nail, remembers the tadpoles, and puts it right herself. The answer comes from something only she could know, because she is the one who took the cup. She also says sorry, which is a larger thing to do at her age than rinsing a cup. Grandmother still gets the last word, but it is now a remark about Pema.
The exception
When to break it
Books for the very youngest often end with a grown-up, or a grown-up animal, making everything safe. A bedtime story offers comfort, and being looked after is the right ending for it.
Where a grown-up may help
Some problems are too big for any child, and good books do not pretend otherwise. A story about a parent’s illness, a house move or a war cannot end with the child fixing it. In those the child’s own smaller problem is what gets solved: how to say goodbye to a friend, where to keep the cat, how to ask for help. Asking an adult for help can itself be the brave act, if the story has made it hard.
On language, reading aloud changes the sums. An adult’s voice can carry a long sentence and an unusual word that a new reader could not manage alone, which is why a picture book can afford words that a first chapter book could not.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Who gets the ending?
In a middle-grade story, nine-year-old twins find that the gate of a canal lock will not close, and a line of boats is stuck. Which ending keeps the children at the centre?
Key takeaway
Write for the child who will be holding the book, in words and sentences they can take in. Then give the ending to the child in the story. Let the adults help with what is out of reach, and let the idea, the decision and the first step come from someone the reader’s own size.
