Four bands on a page
Take a page of a novel and four coloured pens. Mark action in one colour: what people do and what happens. Mark speech in a second. Mark description in a third: what the place and the people are like. With the fourth, mark thought: everything that goes on inside the viewpoint character, the person whose head we are in.
- ActionWhat people do and what happens
- Speech
- DescriptionWhat the place and the people are like
- ThoughtInside the viewpoint character: the inner story
Most pages turn out striped. The first three colours are the outer story, the part a camera could record. The fourth is the inner story, which only fiction can give in full. This lesson is about the proportion between them.
Too little of the inner, and things happen to nobody. A door opens, a letter is read, a man leaves, and the reader cannot tell whether any of it matters to the person it is happening to. The page reads like a report.
Too much, and the story stops. The character thinks, and thinks again, and while they think nothing can happen.
Thought needs room
There is no correct ratio. A chase leans towards the outer and a novel about a long marriage towards the inner, and within any book the balance shifts from page to page. Two questions do most of the work.
Thought needs room
At each event that matters, does the reader know what it means to the character? One line is often enough. Without it the event has only happened. With it, it has happened to someone.
At each stretch of thought, is there room for it? Thought takes time to read, and during that time the outer story waits. In a quiet moment, such as a wait, a walk or the minute after the door closes, it can wait happily. In a fast moment it cannot. If a punch has been thrown, the reader does not want a paragraph of memories before it lands.
So the working habit is this: short thoughts in fast places, longer thoughts in the pauses. One order that is widely taught, and often credited to the writing teacher Dwight Swain, is to give a character’s response to an event as feeling first, then action, then speech, on the grounds that this is the order in which people respond. The Scene craft lesson on stimulus and response order looks at that more closely.
Example
Bidding for a sewing box
A woman is bidding at an auction of household goods. The scene moves quickly, and still we always know what it means to her. Watch where the thought is placed and how long it is.
The auctioneer reached lot forty, and Edna put her hand up before he had finished describing it1.
“Two pounds from the lady at the back.”
It was her mother’s sewing box.2 She had last seen it on the kitchen table the morning the bailiffs came, with a length of blue thread still hanging out of it.
A man in a brown hat nodded. “Two pounds ten.”
Edna had three pounds and the fare home.3
“Three,” she said. Her voice came out higher than she meant it to.4
The man in the brown hat turned round and studied her, and then the box. She watched him decide that it must be worth something.5
“Three pounds ten.”
- “Edna put her hand up before he had finished describing it”Action first. We see that the lot matters to her before we know why.
- “It was her mother’s sewing box.”Thought, placed in the gap after the first bid. Two sentences tell us what the box means. Without them the scene would be a woman buying a box.
- “Edna had three pounds and the fare home.”One line of thought between two bids. It is as short as the gap it sits in, and it sets the limit that the rest of the scene pushes against.
- “Her voice came out higher than she meant it to.”The inner showing through the outer. We are told nothing about how she feels, and we know.
- “She watched him decide that it must be worth something.”Her reading of the other bidder. It is thought, folded into what she sees, and it turns the scene: her own eagerness has raised the price.
The explainer
Move the memory out of the rush
The bedroom, and the first version of the scene, one sentence at a time. The second version tells the same memory earlier, so pressing a sentence swaps in whatever stands at that point in the rewrite. Each clue lights up as the memory leaves the fastest moment and the action closes in.

Changes left
3 of 3
Words
124 (was 124)
Press a sentence to make its change and watch the room.
Before and after
The same thoughts in a different place
The one faultA long reflection is placed inside the fastest moment of the scene.
The footsteps came down the hall, slowly, trying each door. Aidan stood among the coats in the wardrobe with the phone pressed against his leg to hide its light.
The footsteps stopped outside the bedroom. The door opened. A torch beam slid under the wardrobe door and across his shoes.
The wardrobe handle turned. A month ago he had been a man who complained about the price of parking. Then his brother had rung, at two in the morning, with that particular brightness in his voice, and Aidan had said yes to holding a bag for him, as he had said yes to everything since they were boys. Should have said no, he thought. The door swung open.
“There you are,” the man said.
Both versions contain exactly the same sentences. The only difference is where the two sentences about the last month and the brother sit.
In the first version they come after “The wardrobe handle turned.” A handle turns in a second. The reflection takes far longer than that to read, so the handle seems to hang in mid-turn while Aidan reviews the last month. The tension the scene has built drains away during the pause.
In the second version the reflection has moved up into the first paragraph, while the footsteps are still some way down the hall and trying other doors. A man hiding in a wardrobe has nothing to do but think, so the thought costs nothing there. It even adds to the dread, because now we know why he is in the wardrobe before the torch arrives.
At the handle itself the second version keeps only “Should have said no”. That is four words of thought, which is about what the moment has room for.
The exception
When to break it
A long stretch of one band can be exactly right when it is chosen.
One band, chosen
After a run of fast scenes, a character alone at night thinking it all through can be the still centre of a book. The reader has been waiting to find out what it meant.
Some writers deliberately stop the clock at the single most important instant of a story, and go inside for a paragraph while the glass is still falling. Used once, at the hinge of the book, this can be the passage readers remember. Used at every exciting moment it becomes a tic.
Pure outer has its uses as well. A narrator who reports only what is done and said, and stays out of every head, can make a reader lean in and wonder. A character who has had a shock may think nothing at all, and the missing thought is then the evidence.
And proportion is partly a matter of the kind of book. Do not count percentages. Ask whether this moment, in this story, has been given what it needs.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Where does the thinking go?
Bukola has not spoken to her father in six years and has driven to his house. You have five sentences of her thinking about why she stayed away. Where could they go with least harm to the pace?
Key takeaway
Inner and outer have to share the page. At every event that matters, give the reader at least a line of what it means to the character. Put longer thought where the story has a pause, keep it to a few words where things are moving fast, and let any long stretch of pure thought or pure action be one you chose.
