What they are after, and what would put them right
Ask a character what they are after and they can tell you. The promotion. The farm back. Her sister’s killer in a cell. That is the want: an outer goal the character knows about and chases, and one a reader could watch being won or lost.
The need is different. It is the inner change that would put this person right, and it is usually something they cannot see or would deny. A man who wants the promotion may need to stop measuring himself against his dead father. He would not say so. He would say he needs the promotion.
A simple test: you could photograph someone getting what they want. A signature, a key, a kiss. You cannot photograph a need being met. You can only photograph what the person does differently afterwards.
Why the gap matters
A want gives the story its direction. Each scene can be measured against it: closer, or further off? A need gives the story its meaning. It is why winning or losing the want matters beyond the event itself.
How want and need sit together
The two do the most work when they pull against each other, so that the way the character chases the want is the very thing that keeps the need unmet. Someone who needs to trust people, and wants to win the case alone, has to choose sooner or later between the method and the goal. That choice is where a character’s change becomes visible.
When want and need point the same way (she wants a friend, she needs a friend) there is nothing to choose, and the inner story goes slack. When they have nothing to do with each other, the book can feel like two stories sharing a cover.
Example
In a scene
A baker has one morning to win a guild seal. Watch what she says she is after, and what she keeps turning down.
The guild inspectors would come at noon1, and Marta Vey had been at the ovens since two. Forty loaves stood cooling on the rack. She had thrown out sixty.
“Let me shape the next batch,” said her nephew from the doorway. He was fourteen and had good hands.
“The seal goes on my name, Pieter. Not on ours.”2
“You’ve burned your wrist.”
She looked. She had. She wrapped it in a floury cloth and went back to the trough. If the inspectors passed her bread she could sell to the garrison, and the garrison paid in coin, and no one would call it her husband’s bakery again.3
Pieter was still in the doorway. He had tied on an apron.4
“Sweep,” she said. “If you want to be useful.”
He swept. She shaped every loaf herself, and the fourth batch went in late5.
- “The guild inspectors would come at noon”The want has a deadline and a judge. We know exactly what winning would look like.
- ““The seal goes on my name, Pieter. Not on ours.””The need shows by what she refuses. She needs to let someone help her, and she would not put it that way.
- “If the inspectors passed her bread she could sell to the garrison,…”The want in her own terms: the seal, the garrison, the coin. The last clause hints at why it matters, and no more than hints.
- “He had tied on an apron.”The help is offered a second time, without a word. The narration does not comment on it.
- “the fourth batch went in late”The cost. Doing it all herself is now hurting the very thing she wants. This is want and need in tension.
Before and after
The same canteen, two different wants
The one faultThe want is a feeling, not a goal, so nothing in the scene can be won or lost.
Juno Abara had been on Carrow Station for eleven months, and what she wanted, more than anything, was to feel that she belonged somewhere again. She thought about it while she ran the hull checks. She thought about it in the canteen, where the day shift laughed at jokes that had started before she arrived.
“You coming to the lottery draw?” asked Fitch, the dock chief, sliding his tray in beside hers.
“Maybe.”
“Everybody goes.”
“I’ve got reports.” She did have reports. She filed them herself every night, all of them, so that nobody could say the new inspector had left a gap.
Fitch shrugged and took his tray to the long table. Juno finished her meal and went back to her desk, still wanting to belong.
In the first version Juno wants “to belong”. That is a need dressed up as a want. It cannot be photographed, nothing she does at the table brings it nearer, and so the scene can only say it again at the end.
In the second version she wants a transfer, signed by a date, and a clean record will get it. Her need to belong is not mentioned at all. It is easier to see than before, because we watch her turn down the long table for the sake of the reports. Chasing the transfer is what keeps her alone. Only the want has changed between the versions, and the closing line with it; the canteen, Fitch and the reports are the same.
The exception
When to break it
Want and need are a lens, not a requirement. Plenty of stories run on want alone. In a good deal of mystery, adventure and series fiction the lead does not change: the detective wants the killer and gets the killer, and the pleasure is in the pursuit. Giving that kind of lead an inner flaw that the plot then has to cure can make a brisk book heavy.
Some characters see their need clearly from the first page and still cannot act on it. The story is then about the obstacle, not the blindness. In tragedy the need goes unmet on purpose. And a want may be quiet, or even negative (to be left alone), as long as the character does things to protect it.
Minor characters seldom need a need. A want is enough to bring a waiter or a guard to life for a page.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which one is the need?
Dov pilots a river ferry. He is saving to buy a boat of his own so that he will not have to answer to anyone again, and he has twice turned down the offer of a partnership. Which of these is his need?
Key takeaway
The want is the outer goal the character would name. The need is the inner change they would not. Make the want something that can be seen to be won or lost, keep the need off the character’s lips, and set the two against each other so that chasing one costs the other.
