Lesson 13 of 14
Character Village · stone 13Intermediate5 minute read

The detective’s method

How your investigator finds things out: a way of knowing that comes from who they are, used on the page through reasoning the reader can follow, with a blind spot that causes trouble.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-14

Character Village: houses that are each different, windows lit.
Character Village · Character, stone 13 of 14

A way of finding things out

Every investigator has a method, whether or not the writer has chosen one. It is the answer to three questions. What do they notice first? How do they get to people and places? And what can they not do?

A method answers what the investigator notices first, how they get in, and what they cannot do.

The best methods come from who the investigator is. A nurse reads bodies. A locksmith reads doors. A parish gossip reads people, and hears every story in the village by Tuesday. An insurance assessor reads paperwork and knows what a fake receipt looks like. A police officer has authority, a team and a warrant, and is bound by rules a private person is not. An amateur has none of that, but people talk to her who would never talk to the police.

The method decides what the book is made of. It sets which scenes are possible, who gets interviewed, what the clues look like and how they are found. Choose it early, and two investigators with different methods would write two different books about the same crime.

Reasoning the reader can follow

Half the pleasure of a detective is watching a mind work. So let the reader see the steps. A fact, stated plainly. Then what it means, in one small move. Then what that means. A detective may keep her final answer to herself for most of the book, but the reasoning that gets her each little way along should be on the page.

Show the fact, the small steps it leads to and what the investigator does next, even if she keeps her final answer back.

The thing to avoid is the hunch with nothing under it. “Something told her the freighter was wrong” asks the reader to take the detective’s brilliance on trust. A hunch can stay a hunch for a chapter, so long as it came from something we were shown: a look, a smell, a number that was off.

Thrillers work the same way under pressure. The lead reads a room, a road or a stranger in seconds, and the reader should see what she read and what she made of it, even when there is time for only a line of each.

Example

A method in one scene

A retired dressmaker, first on the scene of a death in her village.

The green woolmystery

Mrs Odum did not look at the body for long. She had seen bodies. She looked at the dress.1

It was the green wool, the good one, and the hem had been let down. She could tell from the line of darker green an inch above it, where the old fold had kept the colour from the sun2. Let down recently, then, or the line would have faded to match.3 And badly: big stitches, black thread on green, the kind of job a person does at night with whatever is in the drawer.

Lorna Pike had been five foot two for forty years. Nobody lets down a hem for a woman who has stopped growing.4

“Someone else was going to wear this,” Mrs Odum said.

The constable wrote it down without understanding it, which was what she had expected. She did not tell him the rest. The rest was only a list so far: everyone in the village who was taller than Lorna and could not sew5.

  1. “She looked at the dress.”The method chooses what she notices first. A doctor would have looked at the body.
  2. “where the old fold had kept the colour from the sun”The fact, stated so the reader can see it too, in a dressmaker’s terms.
  3. “Let down recently, then, or the line would have faded to match.”One step of reasoning, small enough to follow.
  4. “Nobody lets down a hem for a woman who has stopped growing.”The next step, and it turns the dress into a question about someone else.
  5. “everyone in the village who was taller than Lorna and could not sew”The method gives her next move: she knows the village, and who can sew. The police do not.

The blind spot

A method that always works makes for a flat book. The useful methods have a limit, and the most useful limit is the other side of the strength.

The assessor who trusts paperwork believes a document over a person, and misses the lie told to her face. The officer bound by procedure cannot search without a warrant, and the culprit knows it. The gossip hears every story and tends to believe the best-told one. The dressmaker sees everything about clothes and may not see that the vicar’s good coat was a gift.

The blind spot is where the culprit can hide, and it is often where the investigator’s arc lies too. The case may be solved only when she learns to look past the thing she is best at.

Before and after

Hunch or reasoning

The one faultThe conclusion arrives as a hunch, with no fact the reader can follow.

Weaker versionThe freighter from Ceres (first version)

Inspector Vell scrolled through the dock records for the third time. Forty arrivals in the night cycle, every one of them cleared by customs. Nothing was out of place, and yet something told her the freighter from Ceres was wrong.

“Hold the Ceres crew,” she said.

Showing the weaker version.

Both versions end with the same order: hold the Ceres crew.

In the first, the reader is told nothing was out of place, and then that something told her otherwise. We have to take Vell’s instinct on trust, and we learn nothing about how she works.

In the second, the fact is on the page in her own working terms: fuel, distance, a log with a gap in it. The reader can do the sum and get there a moment before she speaks. We also learn what kind of investigator she is. She reads the numbers in the records that everyone else has already cleared.

Follow the rule by default. Break it only when breaking it does a job.

The exception

When to break it

Some detectives keep their reasoning hidden until the end, often seen through the eyes of a companion who does not understand what they are doing. That can be a delight, so long as the facts the reasoning uses are on the page. What is hidden is the thinking, not the evidence.

In some crime fiction the method is less deduction than stubbornness: the investigator keeps knocking on doors, and keeps being lied to, until something gives. That is still a method. It decides the scenes, and it has its own cost.

And some thriller leads have no method at all. They are ordinary people out of their depth. Their lack is the limit the story presses on, and part of what the book shows is how they learn one.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 2 min

Whose method?

A writer’s investigator is a village vet. In the draft, she solves the case by noticing a fingerprint on a glass and having it compared with police records. What is the main weakness?

Key takeaway

Give your investigator a method that comes from who they are: what they notice first, how they get in, and what they cannot do. Show their reasoning in small steps from facts the reader can see. And give the method a blind spot, so the case has somewhere to hide.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Your investigator’s method

Write your investigator’s method in three parts, name its blind spot, and test it on one scene from your outline.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.