A label and a bus fare
Tell a reader that Anselm is generous and they will nod and forget it. Show Anselm with one bus fare in his pocket and rain coming, handing the fare to a woman who is a coin short, and they are far more likely to remember him. Nothing was said about generosity. A choice was made, and the reader drew the conclusion.
That is the whole idea. A character is shown most clearly by what they choose to do when the choice is hard. Description tells us how a person seems. A decision shows us what they are, because it shows what they are willing to give up.
What makes a choice revealing
Three things turn an action into a revealing choice.
- A real alternativeThe other road is visible, and it looks reasonable
- A costMoney, safety, pride, time, the thing they came for
- No commentaryCut “He had always been a generous man”
A real alternative. If there is only one sensible thing to do, doing it tells us little. The reader should be able to see the other road, and it should look reasonable.
A cost. Generosity that costs nothing is only good manners. The more the choice takes from the character (money, safety, pride, time, the thing they came for), the more it tells us. Pressure works the same way: with the clock running or someone watching, there is less room to pretend.
No commentary. Once the choice is on the page, resist explaining it. “He had always been a generous man”, placed after the bus fare, takes the discovery away from the reader and hands them a label in its place.
Small choices count too. Not every decision needs a burning building. Who gets the last seat, what is said to a waiter, which call is returned first: all of these are choices, and all of them show someone.
Example
In a scene
A nun in charge of a dormitory finds one girl missing after dark. No word in the passage describes what kind of woman she is.
The lights in the east dormitory failed at nine. By ten, Sister Agnes had counted the girls twice and got nineteen both times, and there should have been twenty1.
The generator shed was across the yard. So was the telephone. Whatever had been at the windows all week was also across the yard, or had been at dusk.
“Stay in your beds,” she said. “Ruth, you’re in charge of the candle.”
She could bar the door.2 That was what the Mother Superior’s instructions said, in capitals, on the card by the frame: AFTER DARK THE DOOR STAYS BARRED. Nineteen girls would be safe behind it.
She read the card. Then she took down the bar3, leaned it against the wall where Ruth could reach it4, and stepped out.
“Put it back up behind me,” she said. “And don’t open it for my voice.”5
- “there should have been twenty”The pressure. A child is missing, it is dark, and something is outside.
- “She could bar the door.”The alternative, stated plainly. It is sensible, it is what her orders say, and it keeps nineteen girls safe. Without it the next line would mean much less.
- “Then she took down the bar”The choice, given as plain action. No adjective tells us that it is brave.
- “where Ruth could reach it”A small choice inside the large one. Even as she leaves she is thinking about what the girls will need.
- ““And don’t open it for my voice.””The cost, in her own words. She knows she may not be let back in, and she arranges it herself.
Before and after
The same decision, told and untold
The one faultThe first paragraph tells the reader what Fenn is like before he has done anything.
Lieutenant Josiah Fenn was the most honest officer in the regiment. He was scrupulous in all his dealings and fair to his men, and the colonel himself had remarked on his integrity. It was not in his nature to tell a lie.
He had eighty men left and flour for nine days. His own belt was on its last hole. In the next tent a boy from his village coughed through the night, and the surgeon had said that what the boy wanted was bread.
On the last day of the month the quartermaster brought the ration book to his tent. Forty men had died at the river crossing. The book still listed them.
“Sign, and the company draws flour for a hundred and twenty,” the quartermaster said. “The living eat better. Nobody in the capital counts graves.”
Fenn turned the book round and struck out forty names, one line each. Then he signed for eighty.
The second version is the first with its opening paragraph cut. Nothing else has changed apart from moving Fenn’s name down a line, and he makes the same choice in both.
In the first version we are told that he is honest, scrupulous and fair before he has done anything. When he strikes out the names, the action only confirms a report. The reader has nothing to work out, and may not even believe the report, since praise from a narrator is cheap.
The second version begins with the situation: eighty men, nine days of flour, a sick boy who needs bread. Nothing is said about Fenn’s character. The quartermaster’s offer is a temptation, the signature costs something we can measure, and the word “honest” forms in the reader’s own mind. It is more convincing for having got there unaided.
The exception
When to break it
Stating a trait outright is sometimes the right call. A narrator with a strong voice may sum a person up in a line and be worth reading for the summing-up alone; a great deal of comic and omniscient fiction works this way. A minor character who appears for half a page can be handed a label (“the sour one at the till”) because there is no room to test them.
A stated trait, set up to break
- Tell us earlyThe steward is loyal
- Then break itHe sells the keys, and the scene lands harder
A stated trait is also useful when you mean to break it. Tell us early that the steward is loyal, and the scene in which he sells the keys lands harder. And one character’s opinion of another (“you were always the brave one”) is not the narrator labelling anyone. It is dialogue, and it may be wrong.
Nor does every revealing moment need a dilemma. Habits, such as the way someone treats a dog or a debt, do quiet work between the big decisions.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which line shows Dara?
Four sentences about the same character. Which one shows the reader most about who she is?
Key takeaway
Put the character where two roads are open and each one costs something. Let them take one, and then say nothing about it. If a reader could name the trait from the action alone, the scene has done its work.
