Starting the book twice
A prologue is a section before chapter one that stands apart from it, in a different time, place, viewpoint or manner of telling. An epilogue is the same thing after the final chapter.
Starting the book twice
You will have heard the advice to cut your prologue. It is repeated so often because of what prologues are commonly used for. One kind is a block of history or world-building, placed up front and given a title. One is an exciting scene borrowed from late in the book, because the real opening is slow. One is a mood piece. Each of these asks the reader to start the book twice. They learn a set of people or facts, put them down, and then begin again with strangers in chapter one.
That cost is real, and it gives you the test. A prologue has to buy something worth it. Can you name the job this section does that chapter one cannot do?
Jobs a chapter cannot do
Chapter one is tied to its viewpoint and its moment. There are things it cannot reach.
- What the protagonist does not knowWe watch the device being fitted
- Long ago or far awayAn event put before us as a scene, for a page
- A frameA teller speaking from years later
- The epilogue’s jumpA year or ten on: what the ending cost, and whether it held
It cannot tell the reader what the protagonist does not know. A prologue can. If we watch the device being fitted, or the seal being hidden, every ordinary scene that follows is read with that knowledge, and the gap between what we know and what the character knows becomes tension.
It cannot easily show an event from long ago or far away as a scene. A prologue can put us there for a page.
And it cannot set a frame: a teller speaking from years later, who shapes how we take everything that follows.
Whatever the job, the section still has to work as an opening. It should be short. It should be a scene, with a person and an action. It should leave something unsettled.
An epilogue is tested in the same way against the final chapter. What it can do, and the last chapter cannot, is jump: a year, ten years, to show what the ending cost and whether it held. It fails when it explains an ending that should have been clear, ties off every minor thread in a list, or quietly hands back what the character paid.
Example
A prologue with a job
Chapter one of this thriller follows Henrietta through her first day in a new office. She notices nothing wrong, and from her point of view there is nothing to notice.
The man who serviced the lifts at the Hartwell Building came on the last Friday of every month, and on this Friday he was somebody else1.
He had the right overalls and the right bag. The night porter, who was watching football on a small screen, signed him in under the usual name without looking up2. In the machine room on the roof the visitor worked for nineteen minutes. He did not touch the lift motor. He opened the grey cabinet beside it, the one that ran the doors on floors nine to fourteen, and fitted something the size of a matchbox behind the second relay3.
On his way out he asked the porter the score.
Eleven days later, on a Monday, Henrietta Blaise started work on the twelfth floor.4
- “on this Friday he was somebody else”The prologue opens its own question in its first sentence. It has to earn the next line just as a chapter does.
- “signed him in under the usual name without looking up”Nobody in the building has seen what we are seeing. That is the reason this cannot be chapter one: no character in the story could tell it.
- “fitted something the size of a matchbox behind the second relay”The knowledge the reader is being handed. We do not know what it does, only that it is there.
- “Eleven days later, on a Monday, Henrietta Blaise started work on t…”The hand-off. Twelve is between nine and fourteen. Chapter one can now be as ordinary as it likes, and every time a lift door opens the reader will be waiting.
Before and after
A lecture and a scene
The one faultThe prologue is a history lecture: a job that later chapters could do in small doses, with nobody present and nothing happening.
For nine hundred years the Nine Seals had held the Hollow King beneath the mountain. They had been forged in the reign of Queen Aldith by the smiths of the Ember Guild, one for each of the old provinces, and entrusted to nine keepers, whose office passed from mother to daughter. Over the centuries eight of the seals had been lost: three in the Wars of the Salt Crown, two by theft, and three more when their keepers died without heirs. By the time of this story only the Ninth remained, and its keeper had been hunted for a year by the servants of the Hollow King, who knew that when the last seal was broken their master would rise again.
Both prologues are about the same seal, and both are competently written. The first tells us where the seals came from, who made them, how eight were lost and who wants the ninth. All of it may be true of the book’s world, and none of it happens in front of us. A reader is asked to learn a queen, a guild, nine provinces and three wars before meeting anyone to care about. Every fact in it could be given later, a line at a time, when the story needs it.
The second prologue drops nearly all of that history. It keeps one thing chapter one could not show: how the seal came to be in a sack of pots on a tinker’s cart. No character who survives the scene knows. The reader does. When chapter one opens on a girl unpacking her father’s cart, nothing needs explaining, and nothing she picks up is innocent.
The lecture gave the reader information, and the scene gives them a secret to carry into chapter one.
The exception
When to break it
Some kinds of book carry a prologue as a matter of habit. A crime novel that opens with the crime, seen by the victim or the killer, is using a form its audience knows well. Epic fantasy often opens the same way. Being familiar does not excuse a dull one, but it lowers the cost of starting twice.
Before you cut it
Sometimes the label is the only problem. If your prologue has the same viewpoint character as chapter one and takes place the day before, it is chapter one. Call it that. And a scene set long before the story can sometimes sit under a plain date as its heading, with no label at all.
If your section fails the test and you love it, look for another home before you delete it. A history that failed as a prologue may be exactly what chapter nine needs.
Epilogues depend on the kind of ending. A love story may want one, to show the couple settled. An ending that was left open on purpose is usually damaged by one, since the epilogue answers what the book chose not to.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which prologue has a job?
Four prologues, described. Which one gives the reader something the story needs and chapter one could not supply?
Key takeaway
A prologue or an epilogue costs the reader an extra start or an extra ending, so it needs a job the neighbouring chapter cannot do: knowledge the protagonist lacks, a scene out of reach in time or place, a frame, or a jump forward to show what the ending cost. If you can name that job in a sentence, keep the section and keep it short.
